Caselaw

Family Case (Ashed) 37081-08-24 M.M.G. v. B.M. z”l - part 6

November 5, 2026
Print

It is therefore a matter of the possibility of revoking the license, along with the auxiliary relief given to the license holder.

  1. In the present case, I am of the opinion that there is no reason to completely prevent the revocation of the permission to use the property, since this would constitute a disproportionate infringement of the company's property rights in the property. However, taking into account the harm that would be caused to the legitimate reliance interest of the plaintiffs if the license to use the property granted to the daughter were to be revoked, it is appropriate to condition the cancellation of the license as aforesaid on the conditions, and even to examine the need to determine an appropriate compensation mechanism.  Given that the parties did not argue at all on this issue, before I decide on it, the parties should be allowed to present main arguments on the matter.  After their arguments are heard, a supplementary judgment will be given on the issue.
  2. For the sake of good order, during the period until the supplementary judgment is rendered, and in order to prevent the aforesaid compensation from being thwarted, the company will be prohibited from cancelling the license and ordering the plaintiffs' eviction and/or cessation of the clinic's operation from the property. It should be clarified that the aforesaid does not obligate the plaintiffs to continue operating the clinic through the company, where there is no dispute between the parties that the plaintiffs are entitled at any time to stop operating the clinic through the company's business platform.
  3. Conclusion
  4. The decision in this case expresses to a large extent the gap between the law, including real estate law, contract law and gift law - from which the legal result is derived, and the just and proper result where the business-family arrangement between the parties in connection with the rights in the plaintiffs' veterinary clinic, which is operated by the company, was not anchored and was not settled in writing. In view of the father's death before the judgment was rendered, in light of its results, taking into account the totality of the needs and interests of the parties, it would do well for him to speak and try to reach an agreed solution regarding the appropriate compensation, which would make the need for a supplementary judgment on the matter redundant, and perhaps even to make additional and future proceedings in connection with the deceased father's estate redundant (taking into account the daughter's words in her application of October 19,2026 for a judgment, according to which she filed an objection to the father's last will).
  5. In view of all of the above, the claim is accepted in part, as follows:
  6. The claim for declaratory relief, according to which the obligatory rights in the property were given to the daughter as a completed gift, is hereby dismissed.
  7. The claim for declaratory relief, according to which the plaintiffs received as a gift the movables in the clinic, including the equipment and vehicles in their possession, is hereby dismissed.
  • The claim for declaratory relief, according to which the daughter holds a license to use the property permanently, is granted.
  1. The plaintiffs will file arguments regarding the issue of the conditions and compensation for the cancellation of the license within 30 days. Defendant 2 will file arguments regarding the aforementioned issue, 30 days later.

The main arguments of each side should not exceed 2 pages. 

Previous part1...56
7Next part
Skip to content