Caselaw

Civil Case (Herzliya) 45864-06-23 Sasson Rahamim v. Lidor Alkobi

October 28, 2026
Print
Herzliya Magistrate’s Court
Civil Case 45864-06-23 Rahamim v. Alkobi

Exterior Case:

 

Before The Honorable Judge Boaz Ben-Amati

 

 

Plaintiff

 

Sasson Rahamim

By Attorney Asher Derech

 

Against

 

Defendant Lidor Alkobi

By Adv. Moshe Michael Kahan and Meirav Maimon

 

Judgment

I have before me a monetary claim in the sum of ILS 180,000, based on an agreement for the lease of a store in a building located at 22 Maskit Street, Herzliya (hereinafter: the "Lease Agreement", "the Leased" and the "Building").  The claim was filed by the landlord, Mr. Sasson Rahamim (hereinafter: "the plaintiff"), against the tenant, Mr. Lidor Alkobi (hereinafter: "the defendant").  The cause of action is based on an allegation of breach of thelease agreement due to non-payment of rent and regular payments in respect of theleased property.

  1. Undisputed Facts
  2. Contractual engagement: On October 26,2021, an unprotected lease agreement was signed between the parties in relation to the lessee tenant. In accordance with the agreement, the lease period began on December 15,2021 (clause 9.a.).
  3. The agreed rent: in accordance with the provisions of the rental agreement (section 9.b.) , the monthly rent was made available for the first 12 months of rent, for a total of ILS 8,000 plus VAT; anda total of ILS 8,240 in VAT supplements, for the following 12 months.
  4. Unpaid Rent: Rent for December 2021 - not paid; Rent for August 2022 and October to December 2022 - Rejected checks (A.C.M.); Rent for January to June 2023 - not paid (hereinafter: the "Rent Debt").
  5. The previous proceeding for eviction of a tenant: Prior to the filing of this lawsuit, the plaintiff took a proceeding for eviction of a tenant against the defendant in the Magistrate's Court in Tel Aviv-Jaffa ( Crim.  Crim.  20869-06-23 - hereinafter: the "Eviction Claim").  On August 27,2023, the eviction claim was dismissed, and it was determined that the substantive disputes that arose between the parties were not suitable for clarification in the framework of the expedited proceeding.  The court there ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendant legal expenses and attorney's fees in the sum of ILS 2,500.  There is no dispute that the plaintiff has not yet paid the expenses that were awarded.
  6. In August 2023, shortly after the eviction claim was dismissed, the plaintiff changed the locks on the leased property and denied the defendant access to the leased property.
  7. The Prosecution's Version
  8. The rent debt is ILS 124,648.
  9. In addition, the defendant accumulated significant debts in the ongoing maintenance and taxation components (hereinafter: "debt for current expenses"). In particular, it was claimed that the defendant had a debt of ILS 20,000 for unpaid municipal tax payments (for the period between January 1,2022 and August 17,2022).  Additional current expenses are detailed ina warning letter dated May 15,2023 (Exhibit 1 in the evidence of the claim), but they are not mentioned in the statement of claim itself.
  10. The defendant's version
  11. The defendant does not deny the claim that he did not pay rent for 11 months, but claims that in practice he did not owe the plaintiff money (statement of defense, paragraph 60), for a number of reasons that will be detailed below.
  12. Misrepresentation: The defendant claims that during the negotiations, he was presented with a false representation that the leased property includes both the store and an outdoor dining area (hereinafter: the "catering complex"), in an area of approximately 28 square meters (hereinafter: the "misrepresentation"). Only in retrospect did the defendant find out that the catering complex was not owned by the plaintiff, but rather constituted part of the common property of the building in which the tenant is located.
  13. The duty of disclosure and the duty of good faith: The defendant argues that the misrepresentation constitutes a breach of the duty of disclosure and good faith enshrined in sections 12 and 39 of the Contracts Law (General Part), 5733-1973 (sections 31-36 of the statement of defense).
  14. Misleading: The defendant claims that if he had known the truth about the catering area, he would not have entered into the lease agreement, since without the catering area, the leased property is not suitable for its purpose (restaurant).
  15. The defendant further claims that since he signed the agreement, he was forced to invest in the leased property in the sum of approximately ILS 400,000 (the "investment") in order to rehabilitate it and adapt it toits purpose (paragraphs 13 and 23 of the statement of defense; Appendix 5 and Appendix 7 to the statement of defense). The defendant claims that he is entitled to offset the investment against the debts.
  16. The Ottoman Settlement [Old Version] 1916Determination of Rent in Excess Rent: The defendant claims that following the misrepresentation (1) the monthly rent, which was also determined in consideration of the catering area, was too high (and therefore the monthly rent should be reduced, and accordingly the amount of the rent debt); and (2) the rent that the defendant actually paid, which also included consideration for the use of the catering area, was overpaid, They included a component that the plaintiff is not entitled to receive ("overpayment"). The defendant claims that the overpayment is entitled to be offset against the rent debt.
  17. 12-34-56-78 Chekhov v. State of Israel, P.D. 51 (2)Replacement of locks in a leased property: It is claimed that the plaintiff unilaterally changed locks after the eviction claim was deleted, and denied the defendant access to commercial equipment, the value of which the defendant is also entitled to offset (paragraphs 69-70 of the statement of defense; transcript, p. 36, lines 9-14).
  18. Charging for expenses: The plaintiff's failure to disclose to the court the core of the dispute between the parties, in violation of the provisions of Regulations 3(b), 4 and 14(a) of the Civil Procedure Regulations; as well as the plaintiff's disregard of the defendant's requests, which sought to try to end the dispute outside the court, justify charging the plaintiff with expenses (statement of defense, section 41).
  19. Testimonies
  20. Attorney Mordechai Shrem and the plaintiff himself testified on behalf of the plaintiff.
  21. On behalf of the defendant, his father, Mr. Mordechai Alkobi (hereinafter: "Mordechai"), testified. The defendant himself did not appear for the evidentiary hearing, claiming that he was involved in a road accident and was hospitalized in the emergency room close to the date of the hearing (p. 1 of the transcript, paras.  37-39).  On the basis of a procedural agreement between the parties, the plaintiff waived the defendant's cross-examination and it was agreed that the judgment would be based on the evidentiary foundation that was laid, including Mordechai's testimony.  His interrogation revealed that Mordechai was the central and active factor in the contractual engagement between the parties (p.  30 of the transcript, paras.  9-16).  Mordechai's testimony therefore reflects the defense's version in full.
  22. Discussion and Decision
  23. I will preface to note that after considering all the evidence and arguments presented to me, I am satisfied that the claim should be accepted in part for the reasons detailed below.

Misrepresentation

  1. The parties present contradictory versions regarding the existence of a misrepresentation. The defendant claims that during the negotiations he was told that the leased property included both the store and the catering area, while the plaintiff claims that the entire process was only about the store.
  2. The lease agreement does not help in this context, since "the leased" is defined in the agreement in a language that can be appropriate for either of the two versions (see "Why" first of the agreement). On the other hand, the fact that in the conversations that took place between the plaintiff and Mordechai, the plaintiff expressed a willingness to bear the payments demanded by the condominium representative (to the extent that they are required), of course, supports the defendant's claim of misrepresentation and breach of the duty of disclosure, with all that this entails.

Breach of the duty of disclosure and deception

  1. The dutyof disclosure is derived from the principle of good faith, which is set forth in section 12 of the Contracts (General Part) Law, 5733-1973 (the "Contracts Law"), and it reflects the norms of conduct required of the parties at the negotiation stage prior to the conclusion of a contract. Thebreach of the duty of disclosure may result in anerror, which confers a right of cancellation in accordance with section 14(a) of the Contracts Law; and may even be interpreted asdeception, within the meaning of section 15 of theLaw (Civil Appeal 4739/19 Y. Meitav Investments Development and Construction Ltd. v. Zar Gas Stations Ltd., para.  24 (Nevo, July 19,2020)).
  2. Taking into account the fact that it should be assumed that the landlord has relevant information relating to the leased property, or at least preferable access to it, the landlord of the property is obligated to disclose the material facts relating to the suitability of the leased property to its purpose. This is the case in general, and all the more so where a commercial lease is drawn up that regulates in detail and clearly the use that the tenant intends to make of the leased property.
  3. An examination of the lease agreement shows that although it stated the defendant's intention to conduct a commercial business therein (section 7.f), it does not refer to the intention to use the leased property for the purpose of operating a restaurant. At the same time, the fact that this was the intention and that for this purpose the tenant was hired is not in dispute.
  4. On the balance of probabilities, I accept the defendant's version of the misrepresentation; and I also accept the argument that the misrepresentation amounts to a breach of the duty of disclosure in circumstances that grant the defendant the right of cancellation. However, the right of cancellation is not a duty of cancellation. Section 20 of the Contracts Law provides that the cancellation of a contract due to deception will be done by notice to the other party within a reasonable time after the contractor becomes aware of the reason for cancellation.  In the present case, a notice of cancellation was not sent and the agreement remained in place.  Since it remained in place, the obligation to pay the rent and any other payment to which the tenant is obligated by virtue of the lease agreement also remains.

Investment Offset

  1. The defendant claims an investment loss in the sum of approximately ILS 40,0, 000. A claim of pecuniary damage requires positive proof by means of receipts or any other reference. In practice, the defendant did not submit to the file any reference or evidence supporting the execution of the investment.  In the absence of a sufficient evidentiary basis, there is no choice but to reject the claim regarding the offset of the investment.
  2. Similarly, the defendant's claim regarding his right to offset the value of commercial equipment that was stolen from him, following the replacement of the locks in the leased property, cannot be dismissed in the absence of any supporting reference.

 

1
2...5Next part
Skip to content