The amount of the claim
- 00A basic rule is that a statement of claim must present a full, clear and explicit picture of the cause of action and of the relief sought. The Civil Procedure Regulations place the burden on the plaintiff to lay out the factual and calculations that underlie his financial demand, in a manner that allows the defendant to defend himself properly and the court to conduct a trial.
- 0In the case at hand, the amount of the claim was set at ILS 180,000. However, a perusal ofthe statement of claim reveals a partial and fragmentary picture: the plaintiff explicitly mentions a rent debt in the sum of ILS 48,124,6, alongside a municipal tax debt in the sum of ILS 20,000. Inthe aggregate, the statement of claim therefore specifies a debt in the amount of ILS 48,144,6 only, while leaving a significant gap from the amount of the claim (ILS 52,3, 3), which remains unexplicitly anchored in the body of the claims.
- Towards the end of the statement of claim (section 23), the plaintiff notes that the amount of the claim (ILS 0,0, 0,18) reflects an estimate that includes "additional VAT as required by law, linkage interest and attorney's fees". However, the inclusion of an "estimate" that sums unexplained sums as part of the amount of the claim should not be accepted. As a rule, the plaintiff is obligated to specify the calculation of components such as VAT, andlinkage and interest differentials; to present the debt principal to which they apply; and to explain how the accounting data reconciles with the amount claimed.
- The debt principal, as explained above, consists of a debt for non-payment of rent (which is stated in the values that include VAT), and a debt for non-payment of property tax. The calculation of the rent already includes the VAT component, and in any case it should not be added again, as part of the estimate. The payment of property tax to a local authority does not constitute a business transaction or the provision of a service in the sense of the VAT Law, and therefore the local authority does not collect (and is not entitled to collect) VAT for municipal tax payments. Therefore, the debt itself does not include VAT.
- As for the other components within the framework of the estimate (interest, linkage and attorney's fees): these do not constitute an independent cause of action that arose before the proceeding was opened andfor which the claim is filed, but rather the accompanying relief that the rulinggave to the discretion of the court in accordance with the results of the proceeding. Mixing alleged material debts (rent and municipal taxes) with future legal expenses impairs the defendant's ability to defend himself, makes it difficult to clarify the dispute, and violates the principle of procedural good faith.
- Therefore, when the court comes to rule on claims regarding the existence of debts, there is no choice but to limit the discussion to those components that were explicitly claimed in the statement of claim (rent and municipal taxes), while rejecting the vague and unsubstantiated demands that were swallowed up in the global estimate.