Caselaw

Civil Case (Herzliya) 45864-06-23 Sasson Rahamim v. Lidor Alkobi - part 3

October 28, 2026
Print

 

Determination of rent in excess

  1. As stated, there is no dispute that the rent debt is the cumulative sum of the rent for 11 months of unpaid rent. This is what emerges, inter alia, from the testimony of Mordechai, who confirmed that he worked to obtain a loan in order to repay the rent debt (p. 31 of the transcript, paras.  25-26).  See also the transcripts of the conversations submitted by the plaintiff (Prosecution Evidence, pp.  30,31,43,45,50,65,66), from which it is clear that Mordechai did not deny the very existence of the debt, but only asked for consent to the distribution of the payments as a result of difficulties in obtaining financing.
  2. In the statement of claim (section 10), the plaintiff placed this debt at the sum of ILS 124,648. However, the wording of the lease agreement leads to a slightly different calculation:
  3. The lawsuit relates to 11 months of rent in total: December 2021; August andOctober to December 2022; and January to June 2023.
  4. The rent set out in the agreement for each of the first five months is in the sum of ILS 60,9, 3 per month; and in total: NIS4,6, 800.  The rent determined in the agreement for each of the additional six months is approximately ILS 41,9, 6 per month; And in total: 57,846 NIS.
  • It therefore follows that in the aggregate, the rent debt amounts to ILS 10,4, 6,46 (and not 12,4, 6,48 ILS, as claimed in the statement of claim).
  1. The defendant in fact does not deny his obligation to pay rent for these months of rent, but he argues: a. The relative portion attributed to the catering complex should be deducted from the monthly rent; and The payments of the catering complex that have already been paid by him should be deducted from the rent debt.
  2. I do not accept this argument.
  3. First, the fact that the tenant claims that part of the leased property does not belong to the plaintiff does not in itself establish a right to offset or reduce the price, given that in fact the defendant received the land and made use of it. In this context, it is appropriate to note the court's ruling inCivil Case (Shalom Bissa) 62532-09-17 Ratt v. Sarid, para. 17 (Nevo, August 9,2022):

"First of all, I would like to remove from our path the defendant's claim that the plaintiff was not entitled to rent out the property since he is not the owner of all the rights in the property, but only half of them.  This argument is futile since, according to case law, a tenant who rents a property from a certain person cannot deny the landlord's rights in the property [...] ".

Previous part123
45Next part
Skip to content