Caselaw

Serious Crimes Case (Beersheba) 20142-08-19 State of Israel v. Ibrahim Shehain - part 23

October 23, 2025
Print

The first evidence relating to the matter is the outputs of the "Itoran" company, P/159, from which it is possible to learn about the route of the vehicle of defendant 2 and his BMW 6X vehicle numbered 9430771 (hereinafter: "the vehicle of defendant 2") on June 14, 2019, with the data in the outputs relating mainly to the hours from 21:26 to 23:34.  Exhibit A/65 was also attached, which is a memorandum detailing an analysis of the documents received from the "Itoran" company, with regard to the said trip to the Occupied Territories and back.  The evidence that was attached also includes the outputs of the "Ein Hanatz" system (P/157), in which Mazda vehicle No. 6903735 (hereinafter: "the Mazda vehicle") is documented and its entry from the Occupied Territories into the State of Israel at the Eyal Checkpoint in the direction of Highway 6 South (p. 44 and p. 36).  In addition, among the evidence are photographs documenting defendants 1 and 2 (P/114), while on the first page of B/114 defendant 2 and Muhammad are photographed on the camera of the "Fians" crossing while leaving for Judea and Samaria, and on the fourth page of defendants 1 and 2 at the "Eliyahu" crossing on their return to Israeli territory.  Daughter/90 is in the memo of interrogator Eyal Saban, who identifies Muhammad crossing the Fitanim checkpoint in a car on 14 June 2019, and the photograph is attached to the memo.

All of the aforesaid evidence will corroborate the statements of defendant 2 and defendant 1 regarding the travel to the area of the Judea and Samaria territories for the purpose of bringing the Mazda vehicle (in which the murder was committed), when defendants 1 and 2 returned to Israel in the vehicle of defendant 2 through the "Eliyahu" checkpoint, and Muhammad returned to the territory of the State of Israel in the Mazda vehicle in which the murder was committed, through the "Fig" checkpoint, all as detailed in paragraphs 5-7 of the indictment.

Throwing the ID plate

It should also be noted that among the evidence presented is an action report (P/96) by the policeman Vladi Melnick, in which the policeman describes that during a visit to the home of Ayman Ashivi in Neighborhood 3 of the settlement of Hura, he located Golda Aashwi ID card in the house. xxxxxxxxxxxxMuhammad's mother when she went out  to the street 10 meters away on the other side of the street, noticed an identification plate discarded with dirty numbers in the mud, and when she cleaned the mud, she noticed the number L.Z.  6903735, when an examination at the car terminal revealed that it was a vehicle that matched the type of vehicle that was at the scene of the shooting in Neighborhood 8.  Attached to the memorandum is a picture of the plaque locating.  It was noted that the license plate was indeed the license plate of the Mazda vehicle with which the murder was committed, and it should be emphasized in this regard that in Muhammad's conversation with the informant, Muhammad told the informant, during a conversation about the vehicle with which the murder was committed: "No, there are no numbers for it" (P/20A, p. 5, para. 29).

Previous part1...2223
24...142Next part