Caselaw

Serious Crimes Case (Beersheba) 20142-08-19 State of Israel v. Ibrahim Shehain - part 35

October 23, 2025
Print

Muhammad's words indicate that he was indeed severely hurt when he received the blow, but he believed that there was no room for insult, and in the end he found what he was asking for (apparently revenge). 

Later in the conversation (P/17A), the informant asks Muhammad , "How much sulha was already? Full, like that" and Muhammad's answer was, "Yes, here no, it does not take a sulha" (ibid., p. 27, paras. 1-2).  And even these words of Muhammad, in which the case under discussion "sulha" does not "catch" are meaningful.

Later in the conversation, Muhammad describes the video of the murder that is the subject of our discussion, saying, among other things, "The person who hit him...  This is one full of him" (P/S17a, p. 29, s. 35-36; See also P/147).

After another period of time, Muhammad was asked by the informant if he had thought about the person who had hurt him for three years, and he replied, "Three years, night and night, day and night......  I swear by the Koran, and it took my soul, Halas...  I chose Halas... And I'm having fun."  The informant went on to ask Muhammad, "The case, may God have mercy on him, you resigned from him,"  to which Muhammad immediately replied, "Calm of mind, calm of mind..... You know he has made me nightmares in my life... What do you have to make me ugly? Who are you, Zelma?  I fucked your mom, I fucked your mom."  (P/20A, p. 15, s. 26, p. 16, s. 30).

In another segment during the conversation with the informant, Muhammad is told by the informant that religion forbids murder and Muhammad's answer is "unless you are right" and he goes on to say, "Yani... How can I tell you? He murdered me and I am still alive" (P/20A, p. 18, Q. 26-32, and see also the supplementary document P/147).

In the above words, Muhammad talks about the deceased, who made him ugly without merit, and in fact murdered him and took his soul, but he "chose", "fucked his mother", and today he feels calm and fun after confirming that the deceased has died. 

All of Mohammed's aforementioned statements can clearly constitute an actual confession to the informant in the murder of the deceased. 

Previous part1...3435
36...142Next part