Request to join on behalf of the Israel Bar Association
- The Israel Bar Association submitted a request to join the proceeding, as an "amicus curiae", on May 16,2023.
In the application to join, the Bar Association argues that the terms of the tender regarding the consideration to be paid to the winner are contrary to the obligation, which is anchored in the laws of ethics, to distinguish between the payment of legal fees and the reimbursement of expenses. In this context, the Bar refers to a number of clauses in the tender (sections 32C, 45,55,83 and 110), including: clause 110 of the tender obligates the supplier, in certain circumstances, to bear legal expenses that will be awarded against the respondent; the tender provisions that oblige the supplier to include in the price quote future expenses as well, which cannot be quantified in advance (except for a limited number of specific expenses for which a separate reimbursement will be given as set out in clause 32C of the tender); Clause 83 of the tender, which obligates the supplier to bear the expenses of preserving archival material for the Respondent, for a period of 15 years.
According to the Bar Association's position, these provisions violate the Article 43 to the rules of ethics, which prohibits a lawyer from giving a loan or other benefit to a client in order to gain a job; the Article 44 to the rules of ethics, which prohibit a lawyer from giving a loan for the purpose of paying expenses involved in providing professional service to the client; and Article 85 30The Bar Association Law, which prohibits the receipt of a total salary without distinguishing between fees and expenses.
It should be clarified, for the avoidance of doubt, that the Bar Association did not express a position with respect to the claims that the tender also violates the provisions of the uniqueness of the profession; rather, it argued only on the level of the distinction between fees and expenses as stated above.
In a hearing held before us, on May 17,2023, it was decided that we would suffice with the Bureau's position that was submitted in writing.