The hearing before us
- On May 17,2023, the hearing was held before us, in which the parties presented their arguments orally. During the hearing, we clarified to the Respondent that we find it difficult to reconcile the provisions of the tender with the provisions of the law regarding the duty to distinguish between fees and expenses.
The Respondent clarified in the hearing, once again, that the bidders in the tender are not required to include in the price quote their estimated expenses for the purchase of professional services; and to the extent that this is necessary, subject to prior approval, reimbursement of expenses will be given from the Respondent (separately from the legal fees).
This clarification is consistent with the District Court's ruling in the Rifand, where it was ruled, "In Rachel, your little daughter", because: "The format of the tender does not include sharing of income, but rather creates a clear separation between the lawyer's fees and the expenses that will be approved, which will be paid to him in addition to his fees" (Name, in paragraph 28); and with the respondent's answer to question 24, in response to the clarification questions, that payment for ancillary services that the supplier will need "According to the Dark Price List"For management consultants, or by way of reimbursement of expenses, subject to the prior written approval of the Director-General".
- Alongside these clarifications, we were of the opinion that a difficulty remained with regard to clause 110 of the tender, which permits the respondent to demand that the supplier bear the legal expenses imposed on the respondent, where "from the examination of the client it became clear that their imposition stemmed from unprofessional treatment from the supplier". This clause raises a difficulty mainly in relation to section 44 of the Rules of Ethics, which prohibits a lawyer from bearing on behalf of the client expenses involved in the provision of the professional service.
In view of our comments on this matter in the hearing held before us, the"The Respondent that the tenders committee agrees Detract clause 110 of the tender. This, without prejudice to the provisions of clause 47 of the tender, which determine the mechanism for payment of fees and reimbursement of expenses to the supplier ("An annual budget framework, which includes payment for all services, including reimbursement of expenses, with the possibility of deviating from this framework, subject to the approval of the Respondent).
- Given all of the above, the Respondent agreed to our proposal in the hearing, that for the sake of clarity and in order to leave no doubt in this matter, the following provision will be added to the tender:
"If the supplier is of the opinion that external expenses will be required for the purpose of the treatment (such as payment to a third party, travel expenses, etc.), he will present them in advance to the supervisor before the treatment begins, to the extent that the requested expenses are approved by the customer, including cases in which the customer requested to receive a number of quotes for the requested service, will be returned to the supplier within a reasonable time after they have been paid.