Caselaw

Appeal Petition/Administrative Claim 1456/23 Zvi Ben-Eliezer v. State of Israel Ministry of Finance, Accountant General and Ministry of Defense - part 12

December 10, 2023
Print

Section 110 will be omitted and notice will be sent.  The removal of section 110 does not prejudice section 47 of the above."

This provides a response to the arguments of the appellant and the Bar Association regarding the lack of distinction between fees and reimbursement of expenses.

  1. In view of this, we proposed to the appellant to withdraw his appeal, while emphasizing to him the difficulty that arose from the timing of the petition being submitted to the trial court. The appellant refused our proposal.

Hence the judgment in question.

Discussion and Decision

  1. I will preface the beginning by stating that I am of the opinion that the appeal should be dismissed. This is both because in my view there was room to dismiss the appellant's petition out of hand due to impediments, and on the basis of the District Court's reasoning on the merits of the matter, which I propose to adopt by virtue of Regulation 148(b) of the Civil Procedure Regulations, 5779-2018 (hereinafter: the SDA Regulations; The Regulation applies in our case by virtue of Regulation 34(a) of the Administrative Courts Regulations (Procedures), 5761-2000).  This is because I am convinced that there is no reason to reject the factual findings set out in the trial judgment; that the findings that were determined support the legal conclusions of the judgment; and that there is no error in the law in the said legal conclusions.
  2. However, before I briefly address the arguments of the appeal against the trial judgment on its merits, I will relate to the appellant's arguments of a violation of his procedural rights.

On this level, the appellant argues that his right to a fair trial was violated, because the hearing on the merits of the petition was held only four days after the respondent submitted the reply; and that he was not given an opportunity to submit written summaries.

I cannot accept the appellant's argument: First, a review of the minutes of the hearing below, dated June 30,2022, shows that a note was given"The appellant has an opportunity to lay out his arguments at length.  Second, I am of the opinion that in petitions filed in matters of tenders, regarding the implications of granting interim orders in their framework and a separate hearing of the petition itself, a party who applies to the court both in the petition and in a request for an interim order, should expect the hearing of the petition to be held on its merits shortly after the submission of the response to his petition.  Third, even if the appellant's argument that there is difficulty, in terms of the right to plead, in holding the hearing of the petition so close to the date of filing the reply is accepted, this difficulty is given to the"Healing" as part of the hearing of the appeal.  As is well known, the powers of the appellate court are broad, and include all the powers of the trial court (see: Regulation 146 To the Regulations"a).  Accordingly, not every procedural defect that occurred in the proceeding below, even in the realm of the right to appeal, will justify the annulment of the judgment; and sometimes it will be possible to correct the procedural defect within the framework of the appellate proceeding (see: Hemi Bin-Nun and Tal Havkin The Civil Appeal 197 (3rd ed., 2012); Civil Appeal 6681/21 Kilker v.  Noam, paragraph 46 and the references therein [Posted inNevo] (12.7.2023)).

Previous part1...1112
13...32Next part
Skip to content