This is also true with regard to the appellant's claim that no decision was given in his application to add the other bidders in the tender as respondents to the petition (application dated October 6,2022). As stated above, according to the respondent's position, the question of the addition of the respondents became redundant since the petition was rejected on its merits, not on the basis of the non-inclusion of essential parties. Without deciding on this, and even if the appellant's position is accepted that the failure to make a decision in his application to join the respondents constitutes a certain procedural defect (and I do not rule so), this does not lead to the result of the cancellation of the judgment as the appellant wishes. One way or another, where the Respondent informed the other bidders regarding the filing of the petition and they chose not to request to join the proceeding (as appears from the Respondent's response to the motion, dated October 25,2022), it appears that their addition did not materially alter the outcome of the judgment.
- Hence the arguments of the appeal on the merits of the matter.
As stated above, I am of the opinion that the appeal should be dismissed on the basis of Regulation 148(b) To the Regulations"A. Nevertheless, I found it necessary to briefly discuss the reasons for rejecting the appeal's arguments on the merits of the matter. Afterwards, I will clarify my position that the appellant's petition should have been dismissed out of hand, due to impediments.
- Conflict of interest - After the trial court ruled that the lending firm would not be involved in the process of selecting the winners of the tender (based on the respondent's consent), the appellant remained with two main aspects of his claim regarding a conflict of interest.
In the first aspect, it was argued that the provisions of the tender regarding the transfer of files to the handling of the lending firm and the management company, which also hold a supervisory and managerial position by virtue of the management tender, create a built-in conflict of interest.