With regard to the claim of a built-in conflict of interest, it was emphasized that the cases that are transferred to the management company and the accompanying firm are cases that the suppliers have difficulty handling themselves, in cases that are not suitable for the handling of the suppliers that win the tender (such as when it is a case of negligible handling, or a low charge that will result in low fees); and in such circumstances, in the absence of "Competition" Regarding the handling of the cases, there is no built-in conflict of interest. The Respondent further emphasized in this context that the source of the appellant's grievance is the management tender from 2016, and not the tender in question; and that in any event, a response was provided to the concern of a conflict of interest within the framework of the provisions in the tender body.
- As to the arguments regarding the consideration of quantitative data within the framework of the quality conditions , the Respondent argues that the reason for the quality conditions regarding the number of lawyers in the proposing firm is professional and matter-of-fact: a relatively large number of lawyers allows the ability to cope with loads if necessary, as well as flexibility and the continuation of proper activity in the event of absences or departure of employees.
- With regard to the claims regarding the violation of the ethics laws , the Respondent argues that the fact that the management company (which is not a law firm) is authorized to send letters from time to time to a local authority regarding a particular charge does not violate the provisions of the law regarding the uniqueness of the profession; and in this regard, the Respondent relies on what is stated in paragraph 31 of the Trial Judgment.
With regard to the distinction between the payment of legal fees and reimbursement of expenses, the Respondent relies on the interpretation of the trial court, according to which the provisions of the tender are consistent with the ethics laws; and this is in particular in view of clause 45.1 of the tender (quoted above), which explicitly subordinates the provisions of the tender to the ethics laws.