The Respondent's Arguments
- The Respondent relies on the reasoned judgment of the trial court.
- According to the respondent's approach, the appellant's petition, which was filed more than a month and a half from the date of publication of the amended tender, suffered from a considerable delay. This was submitted after the appellant had already submitted his proposal in the bid box and after the deadline for submitting bids; and thus constitutes consent on his part to the terms of the tender. For these reasons, the respondent argues that the trial court ruled that the petition should be dismissed in limine.
- With regard to the alleged infringement of the appellant's procedural rights, first, the respondent argues that the hearing held on June 30,2022 should not be regarded as a preliminary hearing only because it was held close to the submission of the reply. Second, according to the respondent's approach, a review of the minutes of the hearing shows that the appellant received his day in court and was given the full right to plead. Moreover, the respondent argues that by waiving the submission of a reply (separate from its response to the request for interim relief), it was precisely the one who waived its procedural rights. Third, with regard to the request to add additional respondents, the respondent argues that the failure to render a decision on this application prior to the dismissal of the petition does not constitute a procedural defect, since the very rejection of the petition, which is not based on the non-joining of essential parties, makes the question of joining the respondents redundant.
- Hence the respondent's arguments on the merits of the appeal; in their context, the respondent relied on the judgment of the trial court.
Regarding the claim of a conflict of interest in the design of the tender terms with the assistance of the lending firm and the management company, the respondent emphasized that such consultation with an external body, which is not destined to be a competitor of potential bidders in the tender, is an accepted and routine matter and is not improper in itself. It was argued that in the circumstances of the case, the involvement of the management company and the accompanying firm in the design of the tender terms amounted to technical accompaniment and assistance in its essence.