| The Economic Department at the Tel Aviv-Yafo District Court |
| Civil Case 9884-06-23 Ohev Zion et al. v. Ohev Zion et al.
|
| Penny | Honorable Vice President Hannah Pliner | |
|
Plaintiffs |
1. Tal Loves Zion 2. Ron Loves Zion 3. Amir Ohev Zion (Minor) Represented by attorney Israel Pfeffer or attorney Rivka Elkayam Brook Mayer, Meitar & Co. Law Office |
|
|
Against
|
||
|
Defendants |
1. Ronen Loves Zion 2. Yoram Loves Zion 3. Achim Ohev Zion Investments Ltd. 4. The Caesar’s Tower (Management and Maintenance) 1996 Ltd. 5. Renaissance Import and Marketing of Construction Products Ltd. Represented by Attorney Yuval Damol |
|
Judgment
Before me is a claim for remedies to remove oppression filed under Section 191 of the Companies Law, 1999 (hereinafter: the Companies Law), filed by the plaintiffs, minority shareholders in defendants 3-5, against defendants 1-2, controlling shareholders in defendants 3-5.
The parties to the lawsuit, background, and relevant facts
- The plaintiffs are siblings, the children of Anat Ohev Zion, may she live long (hereinafter: Anat) and of Eli Ohev Zion, of blessed memory, who passed away on 31.5.17 (hereinafter: Eli, of blessed memory).
- Ronen Ohev Zion (Defendant 1, hereinafter: Ronen) and Yoram Ohev Zion (Defendant 2, hereinafter: Yoram) are the brothers of the late Eli, who jointly held several family companies, including "Ohev Zion Brothers Investments Ltd." (Defendant 3, held by them in equal shares, hereinafter: Ohev Zion Investments) and "Migdal HaKeisar (Management and Maintenance) 1996 Ltd." (Defendant 4, hereinafter: the Emperor's Tower). Ohev Zion Holdings is engaged in leasing properties in the "Caesar Tower" in the city of Lod, and the company is wholly owned by Ohev Zion Investments, which provides management and maintenance services. Ronen serves as a director and manager at Ohev Zion Investments and the Caesar Tower, and Yoram also serves as a director at Ohev Zion Investments. Additionally, Ronen and Eli, of blessed memory, held equal shares in the company "Renaissance Import and Marketing of Building Products Ltd." (Defendant 5, hereinafter: Renaissance, a company engaged in the import and sale of marble, sanitary ware, and construction products). All defendants 3-5 shall hereinafter be referred to: the companies or defendants, Ronen and Yoram, hereinafter: the defendants. To complete the picture, it should be noted that the late Eli, Ronen, and Yoram had partnerships in other companies: "RSI Construction Company Ltd.", "Ganei Bigonia Ltd.", "Neptune Halls Bat Yam Ltd.", "The Central Parking Ltd.", as well as joint ownership In 5 apartments. The other companies are not at the center of the lawsuit before me.
- It should also be noted that during September 2015, an agreement was signed between the late Eli, Yoram, Ronen, and the Ohev Zion brothers regarding the loans provided by the shareholders to Ohev Zion Investments up to 31.12.14 (see Numbers 180-183 for the plaintiffs' exhibits, hereinafter: the loan agreement). The loan agreement addressed, among other things, the amounts provided by each of the brothers, the interest rate, and the date and method of repayment. Section 9 of the loan agreement stipulated as follows: "The repayment amounts of the above owners' loans, as repaid from time to time by the company to Yoram Ronen and Eli, shall be paid according to the ratio between the principal amounts of Yoram's owners' loans and the amounts of Eli's principal loans and the amounts of Ronen's principal loans." The loan agreement stated that the owners' loan available to Yoram amounts to 1,406,666 ILS (principal); The owner's loan credited to Eli amounts to 3,615,616 ₪; The owner's loan credited to Yoram is 116,660 ₪.
- On 31.5.2017, Eli passed away as mentioned. In his will, he ordered that the plaintiffs, who are his children from his second marriage, together with his three children from his first marriage (Eli's children from his previous marriage are not parties to this proceeding and the plaintiffs are not in contact with them - see the statement of claim in section 29), inherit his assets, including his shares in the defendants. To complete the picture, it should be noted that in Eli's will, he appointed Ronen as the estate administrator, and he also instructed that if the plaintiffs, his then-wife Anat inherited nothing except 100 shekels (Appendix A to the statement of defense).
- The Ottoman Settlement [Old Version] 1916 Since Eli's passing, the parties or one of them have conducted (and still manage) additional proceedings against each other in additional courts regarding Eli's estate and the family companies, including in the Family Court. As part of one of these proceedings, on September 3,2017, CPA Yaniv Buchnik (hereinafter: CPA Buchnik) was appointed as the estate manager of Eli.
- 12-34-56-78 Chekhov v. State of Israel, P.D. 51(2) The process of registering the shares in the plaintiffs' name according to the provisions of Eli's will was completed on 14.3.2022 (i.e., more than four years after his death), and upon completion of the share transfer, CPA Buchnik was released from his position as estate administrator. Currently, the plaintiffs each hold 5.55% of the shares of Ohev Zion Investments and the shares of the Caesar Tower (together 16.65%). Additionally, the plaintiffs each hold 8.33% of Renaissance's share capital (together the plaintiffs hold 25% of Renaissance's share capital).
- On November 4,2018, during the legal proceedings in the Family Court as mentioned, CPA Buchnik sent a letter to defendants 1-2 stating the following:
"As part of my duties, various documents relating to the mentioned companies were submitted to me, with the assistance of your client. A review of the accounting ledgers of both companies, dated October 25,2018, revealed that significant changes were made to them according to later instructions from one of your clients.