According to these provisions, unlawful changes were made to the owner's ledgers of these companies.
- According to the documents received for my review, it can be seen that transfers were made in exceptional amounts from the promissory notes of Eli Ohev Zion, in favor of the promissory cards of his brothers, the honorable Yoram and Ronen Ohev Zion. The aforementioned transfers created a reduction in the balance of the right owed to the deceased by millions of shekels, for the benefit of the other shareholders. I hereby inform you, by virtue of my position and the duty imposed on me, that there is an impediment to the disposition of the company and/or its records and/or any other asset jointly owned by the estate and your client, without prior written approval." (hereinafter: Buchnik's letter, See Appendix 4 to the statement of claim)
Several months after the completion of the share registration (And the end of Rowe's role"H. Buchnik as estate administrator) contacted The defendants and their accountants To the plaintiffs for setting dates for fulfillment Shareholders' Meetings, for the purpose of approving the defendants' financial reports. In response, the plaintiffs approached the defendants with requests For information and accounting documents Before signing the reports, For the purpose of examining the companies' conduct (For example, Financial reports, trial balances, and protocols). The plaintiffs further stated that they will not approve the reports until they receive all the information and data they requested. Thus, a prolonged round of correspondence developed in which the plaintiffs requested additional information and clarifications, while the defendants responded partially (according to the plaintiffs) or By referring them to the estate administrator and the companies' accountants. - Upon receiving the defendants' draft financial reports, the plaintiffs raised objections and suspicions of violations of their rights in letters on their behalf. Among other things, the plaintiffs pointed out alleged deficiencies in the reports, such as retroactive salary withdrawals in favor of Yoram and Ronen, fictitious payments to associates and family members, an unusual increase in shareholders' credit balances, and use of the companies' treasury for personal needs. Subsequently, as appears from the many correspondences attached to the statement of claim, the exchange of letters between the parties reached a dead end when the accountants and managers did not provide explanations that satisfied the plaintiffs, and limited themselves to offers for oral meetings or demands for clarification of the questions. In this regard, see, for example, a response letter to the plaintiffs' questions, on behalf of the accountants of the companies Ohev Zion Investments and the Caesar Tower (hereinafter: CPA Kornfeld) dated 15.5.23:
"I request clarifications regarding all the questions; they are unclear (as originally - H.P.). I think a meeting should be convened with all shareholders and their representatives in order to understand and make decisions regarding company management, accounting reports, and balance sheets. The bookkeeping is located and managed in the Caesar Towers-the bookkeeper will know how to provide the best answers" (Appendix 25 to the statement of claim).
- The plaintiffs also approached the defendants' accountants, including CPA Kornfeld as mentioned, drawing their attention to their professional responsibilities as auditing accountants and requesting that they act to correct the deficiencies they pointed out (Appendix 26 to the statement of claim).
- Alongside the parties' conduct regarding the requested information, on 19.2.23 Ronen sent a letter to "all shareholders" notifying him of an option to sell his rights in Ohev Zion Investments and other companies owned by the parties (Central Parking Company Bat Yam and Neptune Halls Bat Yam), in exchange for receiving his proportional share of the total consideration offered by "Maoz Daniel Ltd." totaling 40 million ILS (Appendix 31 to the statement of claim, hereinafter: the option). On 22.2.23, it was clarified to the plaintiffs, in response to their inquiries regarding the option, that the amount offered by the company "Maoz Daniel" consisted of a total of 23,000,000 ILS for the purchase of Neptune Halls and 17,000,000 ILS for the purchase of the main parking lot. On 27.2.23, the plaintiffs sent a response to attorney Ronen stating that they were exercising the option offered regarding Ohev Zion Investments. According to the plaintiffs, Ronen ignored this notice about exercising the option and refused to sign the share transfer documents, which only deepened the severe crisis of trust between the parties.
The proceeding before me
- On June 5,2023, the plaintiffs filed their original claim, requesting an "interim" remedy for the appointment of an investigating accountant in order to "confirm the plaintiffs' fear of extreme and ongoing oppression by defendants 1-2 in the companies" (the original statement of claim in section 1). According to the plaintiffs, the oppression was manifested, among other things, through illegal withdrawal of funds, false registration in corporate documents, and disregard of the plaintiffs' right to exercise the option as stated. The plaintiffs noted that after an investigator is appointed, their right to seek separation relief under Section 191 of the Companies Law is preserved.
- At the pre-trial hearing held on March 4,2024, and following difficulties raised by the court in leaving the original claim intact, the parties agreed to first approach the defendants' accountants together with the plaintiffs' accountant, in order to obtain clarifications and documents from the defendants. It was further agreed that after this approach, the plaintiffs would decide whether to seek mediation or amend the claim, by way of a petition under Section 191 of the Companies Law.
- On April 16,2024, the plaintiffs held two meetings with the defendants' accountants, one with CPA Kornfeld at a company firm owned by Yoram, and the other with the Renaissance accounting firm, CPA Gabriel El Natan (hereinafter: CPA El Natan). Also present at these meetings were Ronen, the plaintiffs' attorney, and Prof. Hadas Glander, their expert (hereinafter: Glander or the expert). On June 4,2024, the plaintiffs notified their desire to continue the proceedings, and on July 21,2024, I granted their request to amend the statement of claim while ordering them to pay the defendants' costs.
- On August 4,2024, the amended statement of claim was filed, in which the plaintiffs claimed they were wronged by the defendants, in the course of exploiting their status and role in the companies; that the defendants pocketed unusual sums totaling millions of shekels from the companies' coffers and made changes to the companies' accounting books unlawfully. The plaintiffs added that although before Eli's death the companies generated handsome profits, after his death, the plaintiffs did not receive any funds. For the reasons detailed in the statement of claim, the court was asked to issue an order ordering the separation between the plaintiffs and the defendants regarding their holdings in the companies by forced purchase of the plaintiffs' shares or, alternatively, to grant any relief to remove the oppression. The plaintiffs also requested that the court order the defendants to exercise the option granted to the plaintiffs by Ronen to purchase his shares in Achem Ohev Zion Investments. To their claim, the plaintiffs attached an expert opinion (hereinafter: "Glender First Opinion, " Appendix 30 to the statement of claim), in which she analyzed the audited financial reports and the accounting-economic records received from the defendants up to that date and sought to rely on her conclusions to prove the alleged discrimination.
- Even after the amended statement of claim was filed (and after the meetings held under court order, see section 14 above), the plaintiffs demanded additional documents from the defendants. On March 3,2025, another pre-trial was held, during which a decision was made instructing the defendants to transfer some of the documents requested by the plaintiffs. This decision led to another request regarding the documents submitted by the plaintiffs, and on 14.5.25 I ruled as follows: "The defendants choose to transfer documents little by little, and from their conduct it appears that documents are located, even though it is claimed they do not exist, and they do not meet deadlines. On the other hand, the plaintiffs raise new demands that go beyond the framework of my decision (dated 3.3.24)."
- After the proceedings regarding the documents were exhausted, primary witness affidavits were submitted on behalf of the parties. The plaintiffs submitted the affidavit of Plaintiff 1 (hereinafter: Tal), as well as a supplementary expert opinion (hereinafter: "Glender's second opinion"). The defendants, for their part, submitted a primary testimony affidavit on behalf of Ronen, and only that. On 6.11.25, a summary pre-trial was held, and in my decision there, I stated, among other things, the following: "I note that an expert opinion was submitted by the plaintiffs, which raises, among other things, questions regarding costs. The defendants chose not to submit an expert opinion on their behalf. And in the absence of two contradictory opinions, I found no reason, at this stage, to appoint a court-appointed expert."
- On 10.2.26, a recorded evidentiary hearing was held during which Tal, the expert, and Ronen were examined. On 17.5.26, the plaintiffs' summaries were submitted. At the end of the hearing, the court sought to clarify (again) whether a comprehensive solution to the dispute could be formulated, but since this did not go well, the parties' summaries were submitted, and I have no choice but to turn to a ruling, first consolidating the parties' arguments in their pleadings and summaries.
Plaintiffs' Claims
- According to the plaintiffs, the defendants Ronen and Yoram excluded them from information related to the companies' business activities and even systematically refused their requests to provide basic information and documents regarding their management, such as financial reports and trial balances. This refusal did not prevent the defendants from demanding that the plaintiffs attend shareholders' meetings or even approve the companies' financial statements. According to the plaintiffs, this withholding of information severely harmed their rights in the companies and their ability to supervise the companies' conduct.
- The plaintiffs claimed that the defendants made false entries and unlawfully altered the companies' books. To prove these claims, the plaintiffs sought to rely on Buchnik's letter and argued that Buchnik, who was allegedly appointed by the court as a neutral and objective party, confirmed that the defendants made transfers of unusual amounts from Eli's probation cards to the promissory cards of Ronen and Yoram, which "created a reduction in the credit balances owed to the deceased by millions of shekels" in favor of Ronen and Yoram.
- It was further claimed that the defendants carried out profit-shifting actions from the companies, converting receipts, illegal withdrawals, and paying excessive salaries to associates - which drained the companies' coffers. To prove these claims, the plaintiffs sought to rely on the draft financial reports of Ohev Zion Investments. According to them, these reports reveal that the companies carried out improper financial activities for the benefit of some shareholders, such as loans mentioned without explanation, increases in office holders' salaries, failure to disclose the identities of employees who benefited from the salaries, as well as a significant increase in interest expenses to related parties. Regarding the Caesar's Tower reports, it was claimed that no loan from Ohev Zion Investments was mentioned in them, even though this loan appears in Note 8 of the draft financial statements of Ohev Zion Investments; It was claimed that the Emperor Tower's report did not explain why commitments to managers appear without explanation for the debt, especially since this debt increased by more than half a million ILS in 2021, the plaintiffs added that it was not given to them An explanation for the high amounts mentioned in the salary and related sections, as well as for doubling financing expenses for related parties, without details about these parties.
- The plaintiffs claimed that the defendants repaid loans provided by companies owned by Yoram totaling "more than 2.3 million NIS, " preferring them personally over the minority. In their view, this repayment was made without a symmetric repayment of the owner's loan provided by the late Eli in the amount of "about 2.2 million NIS, " contrary to the pro rata mechanism set out in the loan agreement, which was cited in section 3 above (see also sections 84-85 of the statement of claim, in Glander's first opinion on p. 14).
- The plaintiffs added that from the financial reports of Ohev Zion Investments, it appears that the defendants withdrew double management fees and salary expenses without proper explanation and approval. For example, "management fees to the parent company" amounting to "240-520" thousand ILS were paid from the Caesars Tower, while at the same time high salary costs were attributed to the two companies (the parent and the subsidiary), which together constitute a systematic drain of their profits. They further claimed that starting in 2017, the year of Eli's passing, an exceptionally new item called "rent and maintenance expenses" was added to the financial statements of Ohev Zion Investments. For this item, expenses amounting to approximately "1,450,000" ILS were recorded between 2017-2022 without explanation for the need for it.
- The plaintiffs added in their summary that from Glender's second opinion, it appears that starting in 2019 there was a decline in the average operating profit, while until 2019 the operating profit averaged about 647,000 ILS, but since 2019 it has dropped to an average of about 200,000 ILS. In this regard, the plaintiffs attacked Ronen's new and suppressed version, which was first given during his interrogation, according to which the decrease was due to two large expenses (rooftop chillers totaling "600-700 thousand NIS" and sprinklers costing nearly "500,000 NIS"), arguing that this is a false claim since Ronen confirmed that this expense was made in 2018, the year the highest operating profit (for the years 2013-2023) of 774,000 ILS was recorded. The plaintiffs further argued that Ronen's version that the decline in operating profit was caused by the coronavirus pandemic or the war should not be accepted, and argued that the war occurred in the last quarter of 2023 anyway. They argued that this decrease indicates an unequal distribution of resources amounting to discrimination against the plaintiffs.
- It was further added to this matter that the ("artificial, " according to them) increase in "general and administrative expenses" for the Ohev Zion Investments brothers also indicates an unequal distribution of the company's resources - according to them, since 2019 there has been an average increase of 470,000 ILS in these expenses, regarding which the plaintiffs added When Ronen was verified with this item, he denied the data and later did not even know how to explain this increase.
- Following their claims in the statement of claim regarding the registration of a new artificial expense of "rent and maintenance, " the plaintiffs emphasized Ronen's various versions regarding this expense, and his admission that a total of 600,000 ILS in 2019 was actually paid as management fees for a "related company" and not as rent. In this regard, the plaintiffs further argued that in the 2020 reports, an additional retroactive amendment was made to the section "Rent and Maintenance, " under which an order of 300,000 ILS was added for management fee expenses, without the defendants providing any accounting explanation.
- Regarding the defendants' claims that from 2021 salary expenses in the companies increased (over 300,000 NIS), the plaintiffs argued that the defendants did not prove their claims that the increase was due to retroactive salary withdrawals, nor was it proven how these withdrawals were calculated, especially when it turned out that Ronen's version that Eli's eldest son received a salary from the Ohev Zion brothers was found to be incorrect. Additionally, the plaintiffs pointed to a 25-fold increase in supplier balances in 2022-2023 and claimed that Ronen's explanations in his interrogation regarding this issue were false.
- Regarding the owners' loans, the plaintiffs rejected in their closing arguments the defendants' claim that they repaired the deficiencies detailed in Buchnik's letter, claiming that not only were these deficiencies not fixed, but additional retroactive changes were made, which further reduced Eli's remaining owners' loans. The plaintiffs added that during the proceedings they exposed a two-stage fraud committed by the defendants to write off a long-term loan provided by Ohev Zion Investments to the Caesar Tower (totaling 1.7 million NIS) - first, they deleted from the financial statements of Ohev Zion Investments the loans granted to Ohev Zion Investments - even though it was not repaid, and afterwards, they retroactively changed the loan in the Caesar's Tower's financial statements so that instead of it being recorded as a debt to Ohev Zion Investments - It was recorded as a debt only to Yoram and Ronen (the managers), while increasing the loan balance. In this regard, the plaintiffs claimed that this move effectively dispossessed Eli's heirs from their share of a loan of about 900,000 ILS and transferred the debt solely to the defendants, something Ronen confirmed in his interrogation with the words: "He looks like this on him, yes." The plaintiffs added that Ronen admitted to making further retroactive corrections to the owners' loans of Eli, claiming he withdrew funds from other companies, contrary to the 2015 agreement in which Ronen first denied in his interrogation.
- The plaintiffs added that the analysis of Renaissance's reports also raised serious concerns about improper conduct; for example, it was claimed that Renaissance's expenses are relatively large compared to the company's turnover; that the gross profit calculated in these reports is significantly lower compared to industry norms, which raises concerns that part of Renaissance's inventory has "disappeared." They further added that they were not provided with information about Renaissance's investment in "Mandarin"-even though Mandarin is Renaissance's main asset. The plaintiffs claimed they did not receive explanations as to why Renaissance's debt to Ronen increased during 2021 and that they did not receive an explanation regarding the increase in shareholders' balances during 2017-2021. The plaintiffs also pointed to an unexplained increase in salary and related expenses in 2021 of about 17%, which they claim were one of the reasons for Renaissance's losses in 2021. Additionally, the plaintiffs argued that Renaissance's reports did not provide an explanation regarding attorney fees and payments such as salaries paid to family members like his son, Gal Ohev Zion, and his son-in-law, Asaf Shoker- who are not employees at the company at all. These actions, according to the plaintiffs, raise concerns about related-party transactions and fictitious employment of Ronen's family members at the company's funds.
- The plaintiffs argued that the defendants' defense collapsed since not only did the defendants not submit a counter-opinion to the opinions submitted by Glender, but their defense relied solely on Ronen's sole and unreliable testimony, while they even refrained from summoning Yoram, the companies' accountants, or the estate administrator to testify, which, according to them, creates a negative evidentiary presumption against them. In this regard, the plaintiffs also complained about the defendants' attorney's unusual intervention in Ronen's investigation, as reflected in the hearing transcript.
- The plaintiffs reiterated their claims of a prolonged trust crisis and sought to rely on Tal's testimony, who described that the plaintiffs live "in fear" due to Yoram's threats that he would "take revenge on us and make our lives miserable." Regarding the parties' dispute over the option, the plaintiffs added that Ronen's testimony on this matter was hesitant, and in it, he raised a new claim that his intention was only to sell Ohev Zion Investments' rights in Neptune Investments.
- The plaintiffs added that Ronen disregarded in bad faith the plaintiffs' right to exercise the option granted to them to purchase shares of the Ohaveh Zion Brothers company. In their view, Ronen acted in bad faith, ignored their notice, and continued to treat Ohaveh Zion Investments as his own. The plaintiffs argued that Ronen's withdrawal from this offer, which was lawfully accepted by the plaintiffs with full compliance with certain requirements and full will, infringes on their rights as minority shareholders; perpetuates his one-sided control over the company and constitutes discriminatory behavior preventing the plaintiffs from increasing their holdings as stipulated in the articles of association of Achim Ohaveh Zion Company.
- The plaintiffs claimed that there is a severe crisis of trust between the parties that does not allow continued joint work, which is also reflected in other interfaces between them beyond partnership in companies: in this context, the plaintiffs alleged that Ronen forged a demand for payment of property tax debt supposedly sent by him on behalf of the Savion local council; that Yoram leveled serious accusations against their late father Eli in a lawsuit he filed against Ohev Zion Investments (Family file 55656-12-21, hereinafter: Yoram's claim) and they also added that in another lawsuit conducted between the parties (Family Case 16590-09-17) concerning the purchase of a plot owned by the late Eli, events occurred involving cancellation of a win by Yoram (after he offered 18 million NIS), contradictory requests submitted by him and by Ronen for an additional bidding on the grounds of a "new bidder" amounting to 22 million ILS, and Yoram's attempt to purchase the farmstead himself (conduct which, according to the plaintiffs, was even sharply criticized by the estate administrator). According to the plaintiffs, even if oppression is not proven, the court may order the separation of the parties in the companies, given the aforementioned loss of trust.
- The plaintiffs argued that while the alleged oppression is proven, all the parameters established in case law for granting a remedy of forced purchase are met: these are a few companies where controlling shareholders are directly involved in management; that there are family ties between them, and where there is a practical absolute limitation on stock offenses. They argued that while in a "typical" small company the shareholders are involved in management, in this case the plaintiffs are completely at the mercy of the defendants without any ability to supervise the companies' activities, and at a time when there is a deep and irreconcilable crisis of trust between the parties.
- The plaintiffs rejected the defendants' claim that a decision regarding the owners' loans should be avoided due to the ongoing proceedings in the Family Court, noting that the defendants chose not to request a stay of proceedings.
In any case, they argued that there is no overlap between the proceedings since the current proceeding deals with retroactive changes made by the defendants themselves after Eli's death Z"L, while the family proceedings concern Eli's alleged actions during his lifetime, and if changes were made unilaterally to the payment cards, the court must order the restoration of the situation as it was before Eli's passing.
Defendants' Claims
- In their defense, the defendants raised a preliminary argument that subject-matter jurisdiction to hear the claim lies with the Family Court, and also added that in Yoram's lawsuit (filed against the companies, the plaintiffs here, and other defendants), he argued that owner 's loans he had made to the companies, which were unlawfully registered in favor of the late Eli, should be returned to him. According to the defendants, the same claims raised in the aforementioned proceeding were already raised, such as claims of oppression, the demand for accounting, the application of partnership laws to family companies, and more. According to the defendants, the Family Court already ruled on the question of jurisdiction on 11.12.22 and ruled that subject-matter jurisdiction belongs to it and that the family companies should be joined as parties to the same proceeding. On this matter, the defendants further argued that in the amended statement of defense submitted by the plaintiffs here in Yoram's lawsuit, they clarified that they would not repeat the claims raised in the lawsuit before me-but these did not keep their word.
- On the merits of the claim, the defendants rejected the plaintiffs' claims regarding compartmentalization and refusal to provide accounting information-arguing that the companies are managed with full transparency and professionalism. In this regard, the defendants emphasized that CPA Buchnik confirmed that the defendants fully cooperated with him and that he (Buchnik) personally provided the plaintiffs with all the documents they requested at the meeting held on 28.9.22. The defendants further claimed that Buchnik even confirmed that during his tenure as estate administrator, the defendants provided him with all the materials required for conducting ongoing audits of the companies. The defendants sought to rely on letters from CPA Kornfeld and CPA Alnatan (CPA Renaissance), in which they confirmed that the defendants instructed them to transfer all materials required from the plaintiffs to the plaintiffs.
- The defendants rejected the plaintiffs' claims regarding false registration in the companies' books and argued that these were claims made without any basis. Regarding Buchnik's letter - the defendants argued that his claims concerned only a change in the record of the owner's loan balances in a way that reduced Eli's balance compared to his brother - and that this letter did not mention anything about taking money, and it was further claimed that this letter also concerns RSI Construction Ltd., which was not attached to the claim here.
- The defendants also rejected the plaintiffs' claims of money laundering, profit diversion, and improper salary withdrawals. In their view, Glender's opinion is based solely on baseless assumptions and concerns and presents no evidence of oppression or illegal acts in the companies. Regarding the plaintiffs' claim of withholding profits from the plaintiffs, the defendants claimed that Yoram and Ronen actually manage Ohaveh Zion Investments and the Caesar Tower, and each receive a reasonable and agreed-upon salary of 10,000 ILS per month for this work. According to them, profits were not distributed in these companies and most are not profitable (like Renaissance). The defendants also rejected the allegations regarding the employment of family members at Renaissance, arguing that these are "baseless accusations amounting to criminal suspicions." Additionally, it was claimed that CPA Konfeld requested to hold a working meeting with the shareholders to discuss the plaintiffs' claims, but the plaintiffs refused and sent threatening letters to the defendants.
- Regarding the plaintiffs' claim about exercising the option, the defendants replied that this is a false allegation constituting an attempt at exploitation and robbery by the plaintiffs. According to them, Ronen never offered to sell his shares in the company "Ohev Zion Brothers, " but sought to sell all his holdings in "Neptune Halls Ltd." and "The Central Parking Lot in Bat Yam Ltd." based on a purchase offer from "Maoz Daniel" for 40 million ILS. The defendants claimed that the plaintiffs' attempt to announce the exercise of an option to purchase Ronen shares in Ohev Zion Brothers for "0 NIS" or for their nominal value of "100 NIS" was done cunningly and in bad faith. The defendants further claimed that in any case, the option was not exercised at all and that "Maoz Daniel" withdrew its purchase offer.
- In their summaries, the defendants sought to rely on a letter from attorney Knaan dated 22.2.23, in which the division of the offer price for the option into 23 million ILS for Neptune and 17 million ILS for the main parking lot. The defendants added that in Tal's cross-examination, she evaded explaining the contradiction in the zero ILS share demand, claiming she was not a legal expert. Finally, the defendants argued that the notice of exercising the option by the plaintiffs did not meet the exercise requirements and should be rejected for this reason as well.
- Regarding the claim that the repayment of the owners' loans at Ohev Zion Investments was done asymmetrically, the defendants argued that only a partial repayment was made to Yoram, because he held the largest owners' loan. They further argued that the dispute over the registration of the owners' loans of Eli, of blessed memory, from 2018, was discussed and is being examined in any case within Yoram's claim in the Family Court. The defendants added that the claim of false registration and transfer of funds is completely false and that the plaintiffs refrained from filing a derivative lawsuit for the return of funds, which indicates the futility of their claims.
- The defendants rejected the claim of the aforementioned crisis and argued that the lawsuit is essentially an attempt to force partition of co-ownership on the defendants under the guise of a defamation claim. According to them, the source of the struggle is the tireless desire of the plaintiffs' mother, Anat, to take control of Eli's estate assets, including the real estate registered in the names of the siblings' parents, since Eli left her only 100 ILS in his will. In this context, the defendants noted that claims for usage fees are pending against Anat in the Netanya Magistrate's Court, and that the sale of the farm to a third party was recently approved, so the plaintiffs' presentation is partial and distorted.
- It was further argued that all the plaintiffs' claims regarding the failure to fully record the income or withdrawals in the Renaissance reports are baseless claims made without any basis, and that the defendants did not forge the payment demand document for the farm; the defendants attached to their defense (Appendix 19) a property tax payment demand for the estate of the heirs of Dalia Ohev Zion - the defendants' mother and me.
- In their closing arguments, the defendants argued that the expert admitted in her cross-examination, which does not challenge the reliability of the defendants' financial reports, and from this it can be learned that the defendants' conduct in the companies was impeccable and that the plaintiffs presented a distorted picture of reality, despite the defendants providing the plaintiffs with all the documents requested from them. They further added that although it was determined that regarding the owners' loan and shareholder rights in the joint companies, Yoram's lawsuit would be decided in the Family Court (which is still ongoing), the plaintiffs did not hesitate to paint a timely picture indicating changes were made to Eli's owners' loan as well as a cash decline, despite the fact that the financial reports show that Yoram holds the largest owners' loan and that a partial repayment of 1.9 million ILS was made. In this regard, the defendants sought to rely on the expert's testimony, who confirmed in cross-examination that Eli's owners' loan was always about two million ILS over the years.
- Regarding the plaintiffs' claims about the salary paid to the defendants, the defendants added that the management salary for the years 2017,2018, and mid-2019 was paid by Ohev Zion Investments in the amount of 600,000 ILS (300,000 ILS each) retroactively in 2019 against a tax invoice, and was classified in the profit and loss statement under the "rent and maintenance" component. It was claimed that in 2020 the company was charged 300,000 ILS (150,000 ILS each) for management expenses under that component, an amount that has not yet been actually withdrawn by the defendants. The defendants emphasized that since 2021, their salaries have been paid on the pay slip and appear under the "salaries and related components." In this regard, the defendants argued that the expert confirmed in her testimony that the increase in the salary component resulted from the salary payment of 10,000 ILS per month, and did not claim that the salary was unreasonable.
- Regarding the plaintiffs' claims about a decrease in operating profit, the defendants argued that this profit decreased due to the defendants' salary components and that in any case, Ohev Zion Investments' activities are influenced by market trends and risks (including COVID-19 and the war). It was further claimed that in his re-examination, Ronen confirmed that he and Yoram did not take a single shekel from the Caesar Tower from 2017 onward, and that regarding the company "Renaissance, " there is an owner's loan and salaries owed to Ronen.
- The defendants continued to deny the plaintiffs' claim of a crisis of trust and argued that these were not proven at all. In this regard, they added that the plaintiffs chose to sever ties with their stepbrothers and the defendants after their father's death, and that in any case, the plaintiffs never took part in managing the companies. It was further added that the plaintiffs' claims regarding the corrupt relationship are puzzling, considering that until Eli's passing , their relationship was warm. The defendants also added that the plaintiffs' claim regarding the forgery of the property tax letter should be rejected since it was proven that such a demand was indeed sent by the council (and that, in any case, according to them, the plaintiffs did not summon the council head for questioning). The defendants added that Tal's claims of threats against her by the defendants were made only during the evidentiary hearing and were not previously presented in her affidavit.
- The defendants argued that the plaintiffs were the ones who knowingly chose not to summon the accountant preparing the reports to testify and not to present their working papers, indicating the absence of any material finding against the proper management of the companies. Additionally, the defendants argued that all accounting records, such as the classification of the loan to the "Caesar Tower, " were made lawfully and that in the absence of investigation by the reporter, the audited financial reports should be accepted as reflecting a complete and reliable picture.
- Regarding the plaintiffs' claims about non-distribution of dividends, the plaintiffs argued that, except for reasonable management fees and repayment of an owner's loan, they did not withdraw funds from the company, and that since Eli's death in 2017, no dividends have been distributed in the companies; therefore, it was not proven that any expectation was harmed by the plaintiffs. The defendants also argued that the plaintiffs' avoidance of including all shareholders and all joint companies in the lawsuit indicates that this is not a genuine desire for a final separation but rather an attempt to continue legal proceedings.
- In conclusion, the defendants argued that no discrimination or even the existence of a "kind of partnership" was proven, since the plaintiffs never worked for companies or sought to take part in their management, and in any case, the relationship between the parties was not characterized by personal relations with the shareholders, which involved mutual trust. The defendants referred in this matter to Civil Appeal 94/20 Tuvia Luskin v. Givot Olam Oil Ltd., published in Nevo, given on 18.8.22 (hereinafter: the Luskin case). They further argued that the companies are not at a dead end and referred to civil appeal 6290/17 Gabriel Magnazi v. Yoav Levi, published in Nevo, given on 11.2.18 (hereinafter: the Magnazi case). Accordingly, the defendants argued that there is no cause justifying the granting of separation relief, especially when it was not proven that the company's activities were tainted by bad faith or fraud, or that unilateral withdrawals were made by the majority shareholders. The defendants added that the disconnect in the parties' relationship stemmed from the plaintiffs ' free will following their opposition to the eviction of their mother, Anat, from the farm in Savyon, which was ultimately sold to a third party, and that the demand to force the purchase of the shares is inappropriate, although the plaintiffs are entitled to act to sell their shares by selling them to a third party.
Discussion, and the beginning of the decision in summary
- After reviewing the pleadings; the affidavits; the expert opinion; hearing the parties' testimonies and being impressed by the witnesses, I determine that the claim should be partially accepted. I believe that the plaintiffs have met the burden imposed on them under the circumstances and have proven that the defendants manage Ohev Zion Investments and the Caesar Tower in a way that infringes on their rights. This oppression is reflected in the burden of expenses on the companies since Eli's passing, with the explanations given for this increase being contradictory, confused, and do not match what is recorded in the financial reports; by making retroactive changes regarding loans in companies, in a manner that discriminates against the plaintiffs; by systematically concealing information and documents in a manner that harms the legitimate expectation of the plaintiffs as minority shareholders.
- I have come to the conclusion that there is a crisis of trust between the parties and that the imbalance in power relations between the uncles (Ronen and Yoram) and their nephews, the plaintiffs, is severe and bitter. I was impressed that the defendants are trying to shift the blame onto Anat, who is not involved at all in this case and has no share in the companies' shares (see, for example, what is stated in sections 13-15 of the defendants' summaries; Tal's investigation on p. 32 lines 21-28; p. 33 lines 3-21). Even if the defendants have a "full stomach" for Anat (and I do not express an opinion on this matter), this does not affect the decision in this case, see my words on p. 33 lines 22-31 of the prospectus.
- I am of the opinion that there is no obstacle to granting the requested remedy in the form described since the circumstances justifying forced purchase exist, as detailed below. However, there is no basis to grant the requested remedy in the Renaissance Ltd. case, nor to order enforcement of the option. To justify my above findings, I will first require the required normative framework; the burden of proof and evidentiary presumptions; the factual conclusions I have reached and the legally binding conclusions, as a result.
The normative framework and first the cause of oppression - the rule
- The claim of oppression of a shareholder in a company is based on the provision of Section 191(a) of the Companies Law, which states as follows:
"If a company's affairs are conducted in a manner that constitutes oppression of its shareholders, all or part, or there is a material concern that it will be conducted in this manner, the court may, at the request of a shareholder, issue instructions it deems appropriate to remove or prevent the oppression, including provisions according to which the company's affairs will be conducted in the future, or instructions to the shareholders of the company, according to which they or the company, subject to the provisions of Section 301, shall purchase shares from its shares."
- Although the term "oppression" is not interpreted in the law, case law has established the perception that oppression occurs when the legitimate expectations of the parties have been harmed, and even in cases where no violation of a right granted to shareholders in the company's founding documents was proven at all, see other municipal requests 8712/13 Adler v. Livnat, published in Nevo, given on 1.9.15, para. 66, hereinafter: the Adler case):
"It seems that in the rulings of this court, the principle has long taken root that 'oppression will exist whenever there is harm to the legitimate expectations of the parties, even if the conduct serving as a basis for a claim does not constitute a violation of a right granted to a shareholder in the company's founding documents' [Cohen, p. 120. See also: Irit Haviv-Segal, Corporate Law, Vol. A, 611-610,635 (2007) (hereinafter: Haviv-Segal); Bahat, pp. 787-789].
- It was further determined that in determining the shareholders' "legitimate expectations, " the circumstances of the case, including the nature of the company must be taken into account (Civil Appeal 2773/04 Natsba Settlement Company Ltd. Atar, published in Nevo, decided on 14.12.06, paragraph 21, Civil Appeal 2718/09 "Gadish" Provident Funds Ltd. v. Elscint Ltd., published in Nevo, given on 28.5.12, paragraph 27, hereinafter: the Gadish case).
- In case law, Section 191 is interpreted as "a general and flexible norm for court intervention to establish a norm of fairness also in the commercial field of company management" (Civil Appeal 2699/92 Nissim Bechar v. T.M.M. Aviation Food Industries, published in Nevo, dated 2.6.96, paragraph 8, hereinafter: the Bechar case). It was also determined that the boundaries of the norm may change depending on the circumstances of the matter at hand (Tzipora Cohen, Company Shareholders - Litigation Rights and Remedies - Volume B, 93, Second Edition, 2008, hereinafter: Tzipora Cohen).
See also in this regard the Bachar case in paragraph 9: