Caselaw

Civil Case (Tel Aviv) 9884-06-23 Tal Ohev Zion v. Ronen Ohev Zion - part 3

October 21, 2026
Print

"The term 'oppression, ' which replaced the term 'exploitation of minority shareholders, ' brought with it a liberal interpretation that facilitates the oppressed minority shareholders to obtain relief against the oppressive majority shareholders...  Oppression of minority shareholders in a company is essentially a situation of unfair distribution of resources within the relationship between controlling shareholders in the company and minority shareholders."

  1. 00 Other municipal requests 8857/21 Tal Ginzburg v. Medipower Overseas (published in Nevo, given on 26.2.23, hereinafter: the Ginzburg case), in section 33, the prevailing precedent was summarized:

"Our case law has long recognized various circumstances as establishing the minority shareholder's right to remove oppression and separation of powers in the company, including: the failed management of a company; ongoing harm to the minority's legitimate expectations for participation in its ongoing management and profit distribution; as well as a severe crisis of trust among shareholders in a private company managed as a quasi-partnership (see: Adler case, ibid.; Civil Appeal 275/89 Davidson v. Ornstein, PD 46(1) 125,130-125 (1991); Civil Appeal Authority 9646/04 Haski Alon Initiation, Construction and Investments Ltd.  v. Aryeh Michelson Entrepreneurship Company Ltd., PD 59(3) 380,383 (2005); Civil Appeal 5025/13 Individual Metal Industries Ltd.  v. Habib, paragraphs 17-18 [published in Nevo] (28.2.2016); as well as Civil Appeal 4588/19 Kardosh-Salem v. Kardosh & Co.  Ltd., paragraphs 16-17 of judgment [published in Nevo] (20.4.2021)."

  1. If the court determines that oppression has been proven, then, as stated, the court has broad discretion in granting remedies and instructions to remove the oppression and resolve the case before it, while not being bound by the remedy claimed in the claim (Adler case, paragraphs 72 and 76, Tzipora Cohen, p. 173). I will discuss this matter later.

The burden of proof required to prove discrimination

  1. As noted in section 35 regarding Ginzburg:

"The rules of evidence that apply in such cases state that the shareholder claiming oppression bears the burden of presenting evidence: the burden of presenting prima facie evidence of the alleged oppression.  If the plaintiff succeeds in demonstrating oppression at this prima facie evidentiary level, the burden of proof will shift to the defendant, who will be required to prove otherwise.  This burden means the burden of persuasion: the defendant will be required to present evidence that will convince the court, on the balance of probabilities, that things are not as they appear and that in fact the company was not managed in a manner that amounts to minority oppression (see: Glickman case, pp.  287,289; Bechar case, p. 248; Civil Appeal 2718/09 "Gadish" Provident Funds Ltd.  v. Elscint Ltd., paragraph 40 [published in Nevo] (28.5.2012)).  The reasons for shifting the burden of persuasion as stated to the defendant are identical to those behind the principle "the matter speaks for itself, " which belongs to tort law (see: Section 41 of the Torts Ordinance [New Version] (hereinafter: the Tort Ordinance); as well as Israel Gilad Tort Law - Limits of Liability B 1258-1259 (2012)).  When all the circumstances and general life experience confirm the oppression scenario, the controlling shareholder of the company is an insider who holds the true explanation for what happened, and in his heart the desire to hide information that is not in his favor - meanwhile, the minority shareholders, who were allegedly wronged, are at a disadvantage regarding their ability to access such information.  This is especially true when the defendant is the company itself.  This mechanism maintains equality between parties in civil litigation when the court is required to decide the claim of oppression-one way or the other-under conditions of factual uncertainty (see: Alex Stein, Foundations of Evidence Law 219-225 (Oxford University Press - 2005); and also Ariel Porat & Alex Stein, Tort Liability under Uncertainty 92-95 (Oxford University Press - 2001)."

  1. Alongside the aforementioned concrete precedent regarding proving a claim of oppression, it would not be superfluous to mention the general precedent that a party's failure to present relevant evidence or testimony within their reach, without reasonable explanation, establishes the well-known presumption that had such evidence or testimonies been brought, they would have worked against them and weakened their version (see Civil Appeal 9656/05 Naftali Schwartz v. Ramnoff Trading and Construction Equipment Ltd., published in Nevo, given on 27.7.08, paragraphs 25-27).

The right of a shareholder to receive information

  1. Regarding this matter, the plaintiffs claimed that despite repeated demands, they did not receive the information and documents requested, among other things by the expert, to trace and assess the nature of the actions carried out in the companies and their books. The right to inspect company documents and the right of shareholders to information is a fundamental principle in corporate law and is anchored in sections 184-187 of the Companies Law.  See also the article by Y. Danzinger, "The Right to Information About the Company, " Boursi 2000, pp.  6-7.
  2. At the core of a shareholder's right to information stand several essential purposes intertwined: on a personal level, it is intended to enable the shareholder to protect their property; to make informed decisions regarding their investment (including the manner of voting at general meetings - see Civil Appeal Authority 981/18 Musa Drilling Ltd. (Daryl King) v. Badarna, published in Nevo, given on 2.5.18, section 6), and to economically manage their actions should there arise a need to take legal action against the company, Its shareholders and organs (Civil Appeal Authority 2903/13 Intercolony Investments Ltd.   Shkedi, published in Nevo, given on 27.8.14, section 58).  The Supreme Court emphasized the essential importance of information in decision-making by shareholders.  Other municipal requests 741/01 Meir Kot v. Estate of Yeshayahu Eitan, of blessed memory , published in Nevo, given on 19.5.03, in section 10:

"Information is an essential tool for exercising a shareholder's right to use their shares and property rights in the company in a way that allows them to maximize the benefits of their property."

Previous part123
4...7Next part
Skip to content