And from the laws - to their application
Was the information required by law presented to the plaintiffs?
- In light of the above, I accept the plaintiffs' claim regarding avoidance of providing information . As stated, the plaintiffs claimed that the defendants exploited their status and position in the companies and excluded them from information about the companies, while the defendants argued that they acted with full transparency, handed over all requested documents to the plaintiffs and the estate administrator, and that the plaintiffs' additional information demands are nothing more than a "fishing expedition" lacking relevance. In this dispute, I accept the plaintiffs' position.
- First, from the plaintiffs' documents attached to the lawsuit, it appears that about six months after the share transfer and the expiration of CPA Buchnik's appointment, the plaintiffs were summoned by CPA Kornfeld to a shareholders' meeting to sign the financial reports of Ohev Zion Brothers for the year 2020. (Appendix 5 to Tal's affidavit - letter dated 22.8.22). However, when the plaintiffs repeatedly insisted on their right to receive information concerning the defendants as preparation for signing the reports (Appendices 6-7 and Appendix 9 to Tal's affidavit), the defendants did not respond at all, even though these documents are required for the plaintiffs' decision regarding the approval of the financial reports.
- At this point, it is not superfluous to refer to Section 185(a)(2) of the Companies Law as follows:
185". (a) A shareholder is entitled to require the company, stating the purpose of the request, to review any document in the company's possession for any of the following:
(...)
(2) In a private company - if necessary for making a decision on a matter on the agenda of the company's general meeting.".
- The evidence shows that indeed on 19.1.23 the defendants responded to the plaintiffs and believed they had fulfilled their duty by referring them "to the estate administrator Mr. Yaniv Buchnik" (see Appendix 10 to Tal's affidavit) and later also to the companies' accountants: "to agree with them on the cost of an hour of work to receive the material" (Appendix 11 to Tal's affidavit, p. 58 of the numerator). I do not believe that these referrals meet the legal requirements - first and foremost, CPA Buchnik ended his role already in March 2022, before the financial reports for a vote were approved. Therefore - he does not constitute a relevant party at all. Secondly - the obligation to provide the material lies with the company, through its managers, and it is not sufficient to refer to its accountant.
- I also believe that the defendants' attempts to present the appearance of cooperation before the legal proceedings proved to be merely superficial, while the evidence shows that even after repeated demands-most of the defendants' responses to the plaintiffs' requests amounted to referring the plaintiffs to the accountants handling the various defendants-without receiving any substantive response to the claims raised in their framework (see Appendix 19 to Tal's affidavit: "For questions regarding the balance sheets, please contact accountant Gabriel El Natan directly"); Appendix 20 to Tal's affidavit: "Questions regarding the balance sheet, please contact accountant Moshe Konnerfeld directly"; Appendix 27 to Tal's affidavit: "I refer you again to Mr. Buchnik").
- The defendants' version regarding cooperation with the plaintiffs in providing documents collapsed even during the proceedings, when initially, their attorney declared that they would agree to disclose documents as required (page 3 of the hearing protocol dated 4.3.24, line 1). It later became clear that even after two meetings regarding the documents, the plaintiffs were not provided with the required documents; see in this regard Glender's first opinion in chapter D, section 11: "I will preface by noting that the documents submitted are very partial and do not provide answers to the majority of the questions I raised, " on page 5: "Despite oral requests (during the two meetings held on the recommendation of the honorable court) and in writing (as stated following the defendants' requests), The defendants did not provide a reasonable explanation or any response to any of the issues raised, " and also on page 20: "It is important to note that although I requested financial data for the years prior to Eli's passing, the information was not provided to me, which does not allow me to perform an analytical analysis comparing the financial data before and after his death, " and also, on page 26 in section 6, In Glender's investigation, p. 18, lines 26-28, and more.
- Even at the stage of document discovery, it appeared that the defendants "choose to transfer documents little by little, and from conduct, it appears that documents are located even though it is claimed they do not exist, and also do not meet deadlines... Regarding the missing documents for the relevant years - they must be fully disclosed" (see my decision dated 14.5.25). In practice, even after my decisions were given, it became clear that the requested material was not fully submitted, and see Glender's supplementary opinion on page 4: "The defendants did not provide all the documents requested by me for the full analysis of the financial statements".... "The additional audited reports received support the conclusions of my initial opinion, do not fully address the questions and issues raised orally and in writing in the past, which require additional information beyond the audited financial statements as stated" as well as in chapter 6 of sections 3.1. 3,3.2.3, and 3.3.3. In which she detailed: "Additional information required for the examination and not provided by the defendants."
- On this matter, I do not accept Ronen's claim that he declared in his testimony that "everything I had-I transferred in full" (p. 47, line 3). First, this was contradicted by Prof. Glander in her opinions as stated. Second, this is also inconsistent with Ronen's consistent refusal throughout the proceedings to provide protocols and decisions of the defendants and his reliance on the terse argument that the requested information is "irrelevant and constitutes an improper fishing expedition" (see response to the request for disclosure of documents and questionnaires, list of plaintiffs' requests, dated 11.2.25, p. 19 of the numerator). In this regard, I note that Ronen's brief explanation in his testimony regarding the failure to provide the documents that "it may not have been relevant to the demand" (p. 48, line 16) and his admission that he acted according to legal advice "what is mandatory and what is not" (p. 50 line 19) directly contradict the defense's version that the defendants did not conceal anything.
Did the defendants meet the burden of persuasion placed on their shoulders?
- If the failure to provide the requested information and the failure to explain why all requested documents were not provided, were not enough, the defendants deliberately avoided submitting an affidavit or even bringing to testify the parties who could have provided the answers to the requested information. In practice, the defendants refrained from summoning Yoram to testify - for his benefit and for the companies under his control most of the loans were repaid; as well as the companies' accountants, financial report editors, CPA Kornfeld and CPA El Natan. It is clear that summoning these accountants would shed light on the material issues in dispute, primarily since they are the ones who prepared the financial statements. In this regard, I do not accept the defendants' claims that the plaintiffs should have summoned them to testify, as these are under the defendants' control, and they are the ones who have the information and explanations for what happened to the defendants. See on this matter Ronen's statement on page 67, lines 15-16 (one of many such that must be said): "Perhaps here an accountant should have stood and explained why he classified it as one way and not another."
- Above all, the absence of a counter-expert opinion and the failure of an expert on behalf of the defendants to address the claims and doubts raised in Prof. Glander's two expert opinions is glaring. Already in the pre-trial session, before submitting affidavits, I pointed out to the parties the absence of an expert opinion from the defendants. The lack of the expert opinion is even more significant in light of the general and concrete precedents mentioned above (see sections 61-62 above): "The controlling shareholder of the company is an insider who holds the true explanation for what happened, and in his heart the desire to conceal information that is not in his favor - meanwhile, the minority shareholders, who were allegedly disadvantaged, are at a disadvantage regarding their ability to access such information" (Ginzburg case, section 35).
- If that were not enough, beyond that, Ronen repeatedly referred the plaintiffs' attorneys to the defendants' accountants or his lawyers. For example, when asked why he refused to provide working papers, he replied that he was receiving professional advice and even claimed that he asked the accountant to provide them, and the latter "transferred whatever he deemed appropriate" (p. 49, lines 20-32; p. 50, lines 18-19; p. 51, lines 1-2; p. 63, line 13). I will note that Ronen's cross-examination suffered from disturbances and objections from his legal representatives, which were also addressed by the court, with all that this entails (see on this matter p. 44 lines 30-40; p. 45 lines 18-23; p. 57 lines 12-24).
- It is important to remember the unequal power relations in the case before us-the founding and adult generation (Ronen and Yoram), who were involved in managing the companies from their establishment until today, against the plaintiffs, the younger nephews who are not involved at all in management, and their mother (Anat) is engaged in legal battles with Yoram and Ronen. In my opinion, the indications detailed in Prof. Glander's expert opinion on certain issues, which I will elaborate on in the next chapter, are sufficient to shift the burden of proof to the defendants, those with knowledge and access to the requested information. The latter chose not to submit an expert opinion on their behalf, and there is no choice but to exercise the presumption mentioned above and to conclude that the defendants failed to convince the court that "the company was not managed in a manner that amounts to minority oppression, " as required by case law.
Analysis of the discrimination claims on their merits
- The plaintiffs' claims of oppression can be divided into four heads-claims regarding reduced profits of the companies by imposing expenses, in the course of allegedly false registrations; claims regarding owners' loans, their registration, and repayment; claims regarding the conduct of Renaissance Company; claims regarding the denial of the right to exercise the option. While I found the claims in the first two headings acceptable (with the reservation to be noted below), I determine that the claims in the last two headings were not properly proven, and I will detail my conclusions in the above order.
(a) A significant increase in general and administrative expenses - attribution of apartment, maintenance, and exceptional management fees
- In Glender's first opinion, she reviewed the reports of Ohav Zion Holdings from 2013 until 2022, noting that since 2017, the scope of general and administrative expenses has increased significantly compared to before Eli's death. The expert determined that the main increase stems from rent and maintenance expenses, management fees, and related salaries, and also added that in the financial reports, in the explanations to these reports, and even after requesting, no explanation was given regarding the nature of these expenses (section 3.3.1.2 of Glander's first opinion).
- The expert referred, among other things, to the reports of Ohev Zion Investments and pointed out that shortly after Eli's death in 2017, a new expense item was created in the form of "rent and maintenance, " which did not exist in the years 2013-2016. While in 2017 and 2018 these expenses were relatively low amounts. (45,000 ₪ and 63,000 ₪). In the following years, this item "jumped" dramatically to 705,000 ILS (for 2019) and to 437,000 ILS (for 2020, it should be noted that in subsequent years it averaged about 150,000 NIS).
- Thus, the expert noted in her first opinion on page 12: "In the financial reports or in the explanations, there is no explanation regarding the nature of the expenses, especially the reason they began to be credited precisely from 2017... as well as the significant increase in expenses in 2019. These expenses amount to approximately 1,450 thousand ILS between 2017-2022, " see also the supplementary opinion on page 9.
- As recalled, the defendants did not submit a counter-opinion; they did not bring the report editor for questioning and relied solely on Ronen's testimony. When Ronen was questioned on this matter, he gave contradictory, suppressed, and convoluted versions, ranging from his attorney's claim that it was an expense for maintenance and renovation work, through Ronen's evasion and his response that the question should be referred to the company's accountant (p. 63, lines 10-13), and ending with a suppressed claim that these were lease agreements signed by Eli "just before he passed away" (p. 63, line 33). These versions not only do not align with each other, but none have received evidentiary anchoring, and I will elaborate.
- The defendants' version regarding historical lease agreements left by the late Eli was not supported, as they were not presented to the court or the alleged agreement expert. The defendants' claim that the plaintiffs did not seek to review these agreements was explicitly refuted by Prof. Glander's testimony, who confirmed that she repeatedly demanded to receive them to no avail. See Appendix 28 to Tal's affidavit on p. 169 of the numerator; Glander's supplementary opinion, on p. 9, in section 3.1.3: "Details of additional information required for the examination but not provided by the defendants... Details regarding the nature of rent and maintenance and an explanation of the significant increase from 2019 onward." Moreover, the expert clarified in her investigation why she requested to present the lease agreements, and I accept the explanation; see on page 20, lines 2-7: "I repeat, I did not ask to review the entire lease agreement with all the tenants, my questions were very specific to unusual movements, to social movements, if in a certain year I see 600,000 rent payments to a company that is essentially the property owner and has rent expenses, then I ask, yes, and that is what I requested, I only asked for concrete answers to the questions I raised in the opinion, not to do all the audits again."
- In the absence of lease agreements, and given the nature of the company (a property rental company (!), and after Ronen failed to provide clarification for recording in the reports at this point and repeatedly referred to the accountant, "this question should be directed to an accountant" (p. 63 line 13), and admitted: "Maybe you are right here, maybe here the accountant should have stood and explained why he classified it as one way and not another" (p. 67 lines 15-16), He is forced to admit that "I have no idea" (p. 63, line 16), and apparently the sum of 600,000 was paid "as management fees" to a "related company" (p. 64, lines 32-33), despite being classified in the books as "rent and maintenance."
- In fact, this new explanation was given earlier by the defendants' attorney, during the expert's cross-examination, see p. 20, lines 8-10: "And if I tell you that the 600,000 you claim is rent - that is nonsense, because these are funds that Aviv Zion financed for the Caesar Tower to carry out renovation work in the building"... To this, the expert gave a crushing answer: "So if you say 'nonsense, ' according to your approach, the financial reports... But if you say "vanity of vanities" and in the financial reports it is recorded as rent, you yourself are now saying that the reports are vanity of vanities" (p. 20, lines 11,15-16).
- Later in her investigation, when asked again whether the request for explanations and how her testimony aligns with her previous answer that she does not dispute the financial reports, she replied: "So on those 700 that suddenly out of nowhere in 2019 it says 'rent expenses.' If it's renovation - at all, there's also an issue with the Tax Authority, because when you record something as an expense - it's a deductible expense. If it's a renovation, then it should be a fixed asset and not an expense that same year also with the Tax Authority. You have to break it through depreciation expenses, so what does that mean? That they spent on renovation and wrote 'rent expenses' and you now boast about it and tell me that something in my analysis is wrong? " (p. 27, line 33 - p. 28, line 5).
- from the explanation of the lease agreements supposedly signed by the late Eli; and that Ronen understood that the new explanation (management fees) casts a very heavy shadow over the accuracy of the statements in the financial statements; and since no evidence was presented confirming that the "related company" to which the management fees were transferred is indeed the Caesar's Tower, Ronen tried to downplay the importance of the classification and argued that "the money still remains within the companies, " p. 66, line 27. This claim also later proved to be inaccurate, to say the least, and in any case, the finding at this point is clear - although a significant expense of 600,000 ILS was recorded as "rent, " such expenses never existed and never existed.
- In this regard, I accept the plaintiffs' claims that the defendants made a retroactive correction of 300,000 ILS for management fee expenses, a correction that the defendants completely ignored in their affidavit, and Ronen confirmed in his cross-examination that: "I do not have the professional accounting explanation to give where this was done" (p. 68, lines 7-8). In addition, I do not accept the defendants' claims in their summaries that there is a charge of 150,000 ILS for management expenses against tax invoices not yet withdrawn by them (section 30 of their summaries) - these are new and late claims, not supported by lawful documents and in real time.
(b) A decrease in Ohev Zion Investments' operating profit starting in 2019; an increase in supplier balances
- Also, regarding the subheading in this subheading, the defendants did not provide a satisfactory explanation for Prof. Glander's findings, according to which the average operating profit of Ohev Zion Investments plummeted dramatically, averaging 647,000 ILS to only 424,000 ILS in the period following Eli's passing (since 2019, see page 6 of the supplementary opinion). Not only did the defendants avoid addressing this issue in their affidavit, but Ronen evaded his testimony, and his attorney had to intervene repeatedly and present arguments on his behalf (p. 57, lines 13-26). In fact, only following these interventions did Ronen present a new version that had not been previously claimed, according to which the decrease stemmed from two unusual expenses allegedly incurred for the installation of "roof chillers" ("approximately 600-700 thousand NIS") and the installation of "sprinklers" ("almost 500,000 NIS") (p. 58, lines 33-34).
- However, this version completely collapses and does not align with the fact that Ronen testified that these expenses were paid in "2018, if I am not mistaken" (p. 59, lines 1-19), and that in 2018 the operating profit stood at 774,000 NIS-the highest profit recorded in all years. Moreover, Ronen could not provide any substantive explanation for the further plunge in operating profit in 2023 compared to 2022 and dismissed the matter with the evasive claim that "it should have received an answer from the accountant, I do not have it at the moment" (p. 60, line 29). The defendants' deliberate avoidance of summoning their accountants to testify on these core issues undermines their defense and establishes the plaintiffs' claim of discrimination.
- I also found grounds to accept the plaintiffs' claim regarding the sharp increase in the supplier balance of Ohev Zion Investment starting in 2023. The defendants did not provide a satisfactory explanation as to why, from that year, the company's supplier balance rose from an average of 0 - 14,000 ILS to an average of 361,000 - 319,000 ILS, while it is clear that this is an unusual and dramatic jump for which no accounting or business justification was provided by the defendants. See in this regard page 13 of the first expert opinion, where the expert noted that the said amount arises "from a balance payment to related parties, in the amount of 175,000 ILS equally to the companies - Renaissance and Y.A.T. Investments... which is a company wholly owned by Yoram, " as well as page 11 of the supplementary opinion. It should be noted that the expert requested an explanation from the defendants regarding the nature of the connection with the companies, but this was not provided to her; see page 14 of the first opinion. I believe that Ronen's explanations on this issue in his cross-examination, when he claimed: "As I age, my expenses increase, so too is this building aging and its expenses are increasing" (p. 72, line 22) are unsatisfactory, and his refusal to present any document regarding these expenses, or at least to provide a reasonable explanation about these expenses, speaks for itself.
- To summarize so far, the expert raised many questions in her two expert opinions, indicating that the defendants acted to impose costs on the Ohev Zion brothers (allegedly rent, salaries, various expenses), all with the aim of reducing profit. Reducing the profit means there is no remaining balance to be distributed, among other things to the plaintiffs, while the defendants receive funds from the companies in other ways - whether by transferring to other companies, as management fees, or by repaying owners' loans - this will be discussed in the next chapter.
(c) Changes in loan records in the books Ohev Zion and the Caesar's Tower - deletion of a loan and its re-registration as a "managers" loan (the defendants) only
- From the evidence presented to me, it appears that in the financial reports of Ohev Zion Investments for the years 2019-2020, a long-term loan was recorded under the category of long-term investments granted to the subsidiary, the Caesar Tower, in the amount of approximately 1.7 million ILS (see the plaintiffs' exhibits, P/1, p. 110 of the numerator). Now, in the financial reports of Ohev Zion Investments, this loan completely disappeared from the company's books with no trace or expression of its repayment (see the 2021 Ohev Zion Investments report in the plaintiffs' exhibits, P/1, p. 79 of the numerator).
- At the same time, a review of the Caesar's Tower reports shows that in the 2019-2020 reports, under the item "long-term commitment, " a commitment was recorded in favor of the "parent company" - Ohev Zion Investments in the amount of approximately 2.7 million ILS. According to this entry, the relative share of Eli's heirs is supposed to amount to about 900,000 NIS; see the plaintiffs' exhibits Exhibit T/1 on page 46 and page 57 of the numerator. Now, from the 2021 Caesar Tower report, it appears that this loan was also completely written off, and under it, a commitment was registered in the names of the managers, i.e., the defendants Yoram and Ronen only, in the amount of approximately 3.1 million ILS (plaintiffs' exhibits, p. 27).
- When Ronen was asked why this change was made in favor of the "managers" (p. 78, lines 17-21), he replied: "So again, I would refer this question again, to an accountant" (p. 78, line 24), and confirmed that at that time there were only two managers: Ronen and Yoram. When Ronen was asked: "We also see that the loan that was registered until now in favor of the Ohev Zion brothers was registered for the benefit of the managers, and also increased by 500,000 shekels, right? ", he replied: "Yes, " and later when asked: "Okay, so basically you are saying, the question is why is it recorded on both managers? The answer is the accountant, not you?" "The witness replied: Correct, yes" (transcript p. 79, lines 1-8).
- Ronen was also asked: "In which year did the emperor repay the loan that the Brothers of Ohev Zion had extended on him starting in 2014?" " (p. 72, lines 23-30, and also on p. 73, lines 15-16), to which he initially replied that he "does not know" (p. 72, line 34, p. 73, line 3, line 17), and later: "I don't remember." Ronen tried to downplay the importance of these registration changes and claimed that "all the funds are constantly within the system" (p. 74, line 2), but when he was confirmed of the discrepancy in the financial statements to Ohav Zion Investments when the loan was repaid (p. 74, lines 17-24), he evaded the answer and directed the question: "To the accountant" (p. 74, line 25). Subsequently, after Ronen was confronted with the financial reports of Ohev Zion Investments for 2023, which explicitly stated that a loan of 1.9 million ILS was granted to a related company (p. 76, line 4), he evaded providing an answer and claimed: "If you had come, you would certainly have opened the accountant's eyes and also received an answer" (p. 76, lines 11-12). There can be no dispute that a reasonable expectation of a shareholder is that the records in the reports reflect reality. Additionally, if a material change was made (the party to whom the loan is repayed), it was expected that this matter would be brought to the general meeting, for a vote, and that all documents and explanations would be submitted in advance. Since this is not the case, it is considered discrimination.
(d) Non-proactive repayment of the owner's loan in 2021-2022
- In section 3.3.2.2 of Prof. Glander's first opinion, it was pointed out that between 2021-2022, loans of Yoram or companies owned by him totaling about 2.4 million ILS were repaid, and contrary to the loan agreement, according to which the owners' loans would be repaid "pro-rata": "These amounts were repaid in favor of companies fully owned by Yoram without reference to or repayment of the owners' loan given by Eli" (p. 16 of the opinion). Ronen admitted in his affidavit that the owner's loan was repaid to Yoram only (section 16 of Ronen's affidavit), but in his testimony, Ronen claimed that out of the amount returned to Yoram (2,350,000 NIS), 400,000 ILS was for salaries (see his investigation on page 84, line 23: "400,000 ILS is wages, he issued an invoice immediately"). Ronen admitted that a sum of 1,900,000 ILS was repaid for loans (p. 84, line 19), and when asked by the court why only Yoram received money as loan repayment, he replied (p. 84, lines 30-39): "I will explain to you, because Yoram gave the largest loans in the companies."
- Later, when Ronen was referred to clause 9 of the loan agreement and the proportional distribution mechanism when loans are repaid and was asked about this: "Forget that they were high, let's say they were the largest, but they had a different status? "... To which he replied: "There was no status; if they had asked, I would certainly have approved" (p. 85, lines 1-3). And when asked explicitly: "Why didn't you divide it pro rata? Do you know the term 'pro rata'? He replied: "I think that if a demand had come - we would definitely have distributed it, I also think there wasn't enough money at that time to distribute, there was only a total of, if there had been a demand - we would have distributed, I approve it today as well, if they ask today" (p. 85 lines 6-11). When asked where the protocols approving the repayment to Yoram alone are, he gave an irrelevant answer (p. 85 lines 17-19).
- I do not accept the defendants' explanations for repaying a loan to Yoram alone, which is not in accordance with the loan agreement. First, I would like to note that Yoram's voice, who is a key figure in the loan question, was not heard in this proceeding, with all that this entails. Second, even assuming Yoram gave the highest loans to the companies (and I do not make a finding on this matter), this does not justify ignoring the mechanism set forth in the loan agreement to which everyone is signed. Third - Yoram's disavowal of the loan agreement is a claim being examined in the Family Court, and at this stage, as long as his claims are not resolved, the agreement is binding in every respect and cannot be acted contrary to. Fourth - The fact that the parties did not approach arbitration regarding the interpretation of the loan agreement (see Ronen's testimony on p. 85, lines 32-34) also does not justify its unilateral cancellation.
- From the collected material, a clear picture emerges- after Eli's death, owners' loans were repaid solely for Yoram. This repayment was made contrary to the mechanism set in the loan agreement; This should be seen as harming the plaintiffs' expectation to receive their proportional share of loan repayments, amounting to minority discrimination.
(e) Retroactive reduction of the balances of the owner's loan that was registered in Eli's name until his death - subject to review
- The plaintiffs claimed that after Eli's death, the defendants made changes to the Ohev Zion Investments registration card and reduced the remaining owners' loan registered in Eli's name by 980,000 ILS. In this regard, the plaintiffs relied on the working papers they received from the defendants; Glender's opinion (see Glander's first opinion in section 3.3.2.2). and also in Glender's supplementary opinion in section 3.1.1.e: "It was found that entries were made in the company's accounting documents in a way that reduced the company's debt balance to the late Eli by about 980,000 NIS" and the Buchnik letter. The defendants rejected this claim and argued that the loan amounts of Eli's owners always amounted to about two million ILS and that the correction made was canceled (section 19 of Ronen's affidavit, Ronen's investigation p. 80, line 21).
- From the evidentiary basis presented to me, a picture emerges that allegedly, between May and October 2018, retroactive journal entries for 2016 were recorded in Ohev Zion Investments' reports (i.e., for one year before Eli's death), in which the defendants reduced Eli's opening balances while simultaneously increasing the company's debt balances to the defendants by 900,000 ILS.
- In Glender's first opinion on page 15, she examined the balance sheet report for 2016 and showed that although on 29.5.18 it was written that Eli's owners' loan balance was 3.9 million ILS, on 22.10.18 it was written that it decreased to 2.9 million ILS, and simultaneously, as mentioned, the company's debt balance to the defendants increased by about 900,000 ILS. Regarding this, Glander stated that it had no information regarding the date and nature of the transfer of the journal entries for the years 2018-2019, and therefore it cannot "conclude whether the journal entries totaling approximately 900,000 ILS were canceled and the balances reverted to their previous levels (and if so, why?), or whether the above amount was withdrawn by the brothers and the balance is smaller according to the withdrawal amount."
- Ronen claimed that the "correction" in this entry was "canceled, " but did not provide documents regarding the repayment of the owners' loans or the changes made (p. 83, lines 9-10, line 30: "I need to check with my accountant"). He later even presented a rolling version regarding the offset actions (for the late Eli's loan) and the repayment (for the defendants). At first, he claimed: "The only one who got a refund was Yoram" (p. 83, line 20) and that "it is very possible (Shali - my note) he withdrew from other notebooks and then made the deduction here, I need to check, I have the answer now" (p. 83, lines 22-24). When asked when Eli withdrew the money, he replied: "After he passed away, Yes, if he had withdrawals beforehand, it is possible" (line 28).
- It is not superfluous to mention Buchnik's letter, which stated: "Transfers in amounts exceeding the promissory notes of Eli Ohev Zion, for the benefit of the promissory cards of his brothers, the honorable Yoram and Ronen Ohave-Zion. These transfers created a reduction in the remaining credit owed to the deceased by millions of shekels, for the benefit of the other shareholders." I do not accept the defendants' claim that Buchnik's letter dated 4.10.23, which confirms that the defendants fully cooperated with him (for audit purposes), indicates that the records were corrected, especially since Buchnik was only involved in March 2022; The 2021 reports were approved only later, and he had no criticism regarding what had happened since his departure.
- Despite the indications presented above and presented to me regarding retroactive changes to the registered owners' loans, I chose not to make a conclusive finding on this matter. As mentioned above, in the Family Court, Yoram's lawsuit concerning the owners' loans is ongoing (Family Case 55656-12-21). A review of the statement of claim in Yoram's lawsuit (attached as Appendix B to Ronen's affidavit) shows that Ronen's main claim in that proceeding is that over the years he transferred owners' loans to the family companies at a significantly higher rate than the owners' loans provided by the other brothers without signing formal loan agreements (sections 17 and 28 of Yoram's claim). In this lawsuit, he sought the restitution of funds. From that lawsuit, it appears that although the claim is over 5 million ILS, only 900,000 ILS is attributed to Ohav Zion Holdings (section 10 of Yoram's claim), and in fact, the claim mainly concerns other defendants who are not part of this proceeding at all ("White Sukkah, " sections 7-8 of Yoram's claim, "The Central Parking Company, " section 9 of Yoram's lawsuit, see also the other defendants in the same lawsuit, such as Defendant 2 there - RSI Construction Company Ltd.).
- It seems that the issue of the aforementioned loan amounts (and documented, unlike my findings in sections 92-99 above, which stand regardless of the Family Court's ruling) will be fully discussed in the parallel proceeding. In practice, a procedural agreement was given on this already at the pre-trial hearing held before me on 6.11.25, when the plaintiffs' attorney declared as follows: "There is one point regarding the owners' loans that is part of the lawsuit, where if my lady decides not to discuss this matter, it is possible to put an asterisk and not discuss it, and we will address costs, and as the proceedings there become clear, if we proceed according to Her Excellency's decision, we understand the matter; it is an overlapping point" (transcript p. 10, lines 21-24). Therefore, I do not make a factual finding regarding what is mentioned in this subchapter, and the decision regarding the amount of the owner's loans granted by each shareholder to the companies will be decided by the Family Court.
Additional claims of discrimination - rejected