The plaintiffs' claim regarding the exercise of the option
- I reject the plaintiffs' claim regarding the exercise of the option. In Ronen's letter dated 17.2. 23 it was explicitly stated: "I hereby inform you that I intend to sell all my shares/rights in the three companies in question... Failure to provide a positive response regarding the two companies; Central Parking Company Bat Yam Ltd.. and Achim Ohev Zion Investments Ltd. Within 10 days... will be considered your refusal to purchase my shares...". In another document sent on behalf of Ronen's attorney on 22.2.23, it was clarified that the offer in question explicitly referred to a deal with Maoz Daniel Ltd. to purchase Ronen's rights in Neptune Halls and the Central Parking Company totaling 40,000,000 ILS, while Ohev Zion Investments was mentioned solely due to its indirect holdings in these companies.
- I believe that the interpretation that consideration could have been offered solely for Ohev Zion Investments does not align with the offer and clarification given; I believe that on the face of it, it is illogical that Ohev Zion Investments shares are worth 0 ILS or at their nominal value of 100 NIS; Ohev Zion Investments owns real estate with significant value, and therefore the offer made does not constitute an "exercise of option" and there was no basis for accepting it.
Claims of discrimination at Renaissance Company
- Regarding Renaissance Company, the plaintiffs' claims were presented to me that over the years since Eli's passing, there has been a significant deterioration in its revenues and business condition, and that the source of this deterioration is the burden of expenses, unlawful withdrawals, or excessive salary payments made by Ronen (these claims were extensively presented in a letter sent to Ronen (with a copy to CPA Renaissance) on 11.5.2023, which was attached as Appendix 23 to Tal's affidavit). The court was presented with Prof. Glander's opinion, which pointed to an alleged decrease in Renaissance's annual revenues (including the Mandarin partnership, partly held by Renaissance) from about 2.1 to 2.8 million ILS in 2013-2016, to only 1.3 to 1.8 million ILS starting in 2017.
- The expert further pointed out that from the date of Eli's passing, Renaissance transformed from a profitable company into a loss-making company (see section 3.3.2 of the supplementary opinion, and section 3.3.1 of the first opinion). It was also presented to me that during the years following Eli's death, there was a significant increase in the credit balances of the company's shareholders. In these matters, the plaintiffs claimed that their expert was not provided with adequate explanations regarding Renaissance's financial decline, nor were detailed ledgers of the shareholders provided to determine the true nature of these balances (section 3.3.3 of the supplementary opinion and section 5.3.1.2 of the first opinion). On the other hand, the defendants rejected these claims and sought to dismiss them, arguing that Renaissance is a non-profitable company and that Prof. Glander's opinion does not establish a positive finding of actual oppression but relies solely on "concerns" and "assumptions" (see sections 15 and 21 of the amended defense).
- I considered the evidence presented to me; I did not ignore the claim that the defendants, even in this matter, did not provide documents/explanations/witnesses, etc. However, unlike my findings regarding Ohev Zion Investments, I believe that the plaintiffs' findings, on whom the initial burden rests, are insufficient. Thus, even in the first Glander opinion, it is stated in section 5.3.2.1: "It is evident that the scope of general and administrative expenses has been stable over the years examined... "; See section 3.3.2 of Glender's second opinion: "In the years 2014-2016, the company was profitable, whereas starting in 2017, this year it turned to a loss, except for 2020 and 2022 when a profit was recorded." That is to say, even the data in the expert opinion are not conclusive. To this we add the fact that no evidence was found of profit shifting to other companies or false records, as was discovered in the Ohev Zion Investment case (see the "rent" component); No indications were presented of unfair loan repayments, as was discovered in the Ohev Zion Investments case. Therefore, I found no reason to accept the claim of oppression regarding Renaissance.
Forced Purchase as a Remedy to Remove Deprivation