A supplier of a company demanded that a shareholder of a company, who was also in practice its CFO, be required to personally pay the company debts for goods supplied, after presenting him with presentations that the company cash flow difficulties were easy and not a real financial hardship with an apprehension of non-payment and he continued to issue checks and sign them The Court attributed the company debt to the shareholder personally as he managed the company with thin capitalization and hid its true financial situation from the company creditor. A personal liability of a company shareholder will be imposed in exceptional cases where the special conditions for piercing the corporate veil are met. Managing a company in a state of thin capitalization, which occurs when the company equity or asset inventory is not sufficient to cover the company liabilities, is a prohibited use of the incorporation veil because the shareholder 'enjoys' the company profit prospects, but does not share the risks of loss - which are rolled over to the shoulders of the external creditors. Additionally, an organ of a company is not exempt of personal liability if acted in an undue manner towards third parties. In this case, the shareholder knew that the company debts exceeded the value of its assets but despite this the company continued, with his knowledge, to order goods and issue future checks without cover. In addition, his role in the management of the company included personally signing company checks, and accordingly reviewing its financial conduct, therefore he had a duty of care towards the supplier as part of the general duty of care of a CFO in a company vis-à-vis its creditors who rely on his representations. Therefore, the shareholder is personally liable for the company debts.
Published in Afik News 375 30.11.2022
Related articles
An “AS IS” clause does not override the duty of good faith and the prohibition of misrepresentation.
Mergers and Acquisitions
Dispute Resolution
A couple invested in a startup for distributing online courses. The project developers presented them with a representation that the technological system was almost completely ready, of high quality, and that significant resources had been invested in it. The agreement between the parties stated that the system is purchased in its current condition (“AS IS”). […]
The consent not to apply the Property Relations Law to spouses must be given following a detailed explanation from the certifying authority
Notarial Prenups
Notarial Services
Dispute Resolution
In a marriage contract entered into between a Muslim couple it was stated that only Sharia law would apply to their marriage, and not the Israeli Property Relations Law. The marriage contract was signed by both spouses, but the implication of applying Sharia law instead of the Property Relations Law was not explained to them […]
A mediation agreement is based on the independent consent of the parties with the assistance of the mediator, who does not dictate its content
Real estate in Israel and around the world
Dispute Resolution
Rights holders held the land by virtue of a judgment and a division map. A decade after the judgment, a mediation process took place regarding a family dispute between other partners in the plot, without involving the two original rights holders. The mediation agreement was granted the status of a judgment, but it contradicted the […]
A bank may prohibit cash deposits due to money laundering concerns
Commercial, Banking and Financial
Dispute Resolution
An association deposited significant amounts of cash collected as donations into its bank account, without identifying their source. Consequently, and against the backdrop of various media reports raising suspicions of its involvement in terror financing, the bank decided to completely block its account activity. The Court held that the bank must refrain from closing the […]