A director and a controlling shareholder of the company filed a claim asking the court to recognize him as an employee of the company and to grant him all the rights to which he is entitled to as an employee, for the services he provided to the company as a director. The court held that in order to determine the nature of the relations between the parties and to determine whether labor relations existed between them, it is not sufficient to determine the agreements between the parties. Also, a director acting only as part of his position on the board, and even if he receives any compensation for that service, is not considered as an employee of the company. Since in this case the director failed to prove by the combined test that there are indicators that he is an employee of the company (since this was not his only job, since he did not have an office in the company, and many other indicators), the court rejected the claim.
Published in Afik News 231 24.05.2017
Related articles
When the dispute remains alive, a claim for offset can be raised even after the cause of action’s statute of limitation period has expired
Real estate in Israel and around the world
Public Law, Elections Law and Tenders
Dispute Resolution
A company sought to offset royalty amounts that were collected in excess from future royalties to the Israel Land Authority. This was done in light of the fact that the statute of limitation period for the cause of action for the collection in excess expired and the Israel Land Authority knew that the company maintains […]
A negative past record may result in the disqualification of a tender bid
Public Law, Elections Law and Tenders
Dispute Resolution
A tenders committee disqualified a sole bid in a tender for the provision of cleaning services due to the bidder’s negative past record. The Court dismissed the petition and held that the tenders committee’s decision to reject the bid based on the negative record was free of flaw. Intervention in the professional discretion of the […]
A partner who terminates a partnership agreement in bad faith may be obligated to pay compensation for loss of entrepreneurial profit
Business, Corporate and Joint Ventures
Dispute Resolution
A farm owner terminated a partnership agreement with a company engaged in the marketing and construction of solar systems in favor of an engagement with a competing company, contending that he was entitled to terminate the partnership agreement at any time. The Court partially accepted the claim and the farm owner is to pay compensation […]
Even if a will expresses the free will of the testator it does not mean that the testator was necessarily qualified to make it
Wills and Estates
Notarial wills and testaments
Intergenerational Law (Trusts, Estates, Lasting Powers of Attorney, Parenting)
A woman made a will in 2012 in which she distributed her property to her three children. In 2017, after it was determined that she did not need a guardian despite being an 84-year-old and nursed, she made a will in a haste before a notary who did not ask her for a medical certificate, […]