A director and a controlling shareholder of the company filed a claim asking the court to recognize him as an employee of the company and to grant him all the rights to which he is entitled to as an employee, for the services he provided to the company as a director. The court held that in order to determine the nature of the relations between the parties and to determine whether labor relations existed between them, it is not sufficient to determine the agreements between the parties. Also, a director acting only as part of his position on the board, and even if he receives any compensation for that service, is not considered as an employee of the company. Since in this case the director failed to prove by the combined test that there are indicators that he is an employee of the company (since this was not his only job, since he did not have an office in the company, and many other indicators), the court rejected the claim.
Published in Afik News 231 24.05.2017
Related articles
Approval of CEO compensation via over-ruling requires addressing shareholders’ opposition
Capital Markets and Stock Exchange Regulations
Dispute Resolution
Business, Corporate and Joint Ventures
After the general assembly of shareholders in a public company rejected the decision of the compensation committee and the board of directors of the company to grant the CEO a special bonus that deviates from the company’s compensation policy, the bonus was approved via an “overruling” decision. The Court dismissed the company’s motion for summary […]
When a Court has jurisdiction the burden of proving the existence of a proper forum outside of Israel falls on the defendant
International Transactions and Disputes and Israeli “Soft Landing”
Dispute Resolution
An Israeli lawyer, sued by an Israeli investor who had entered into a real estate investment agreement abroad through the lawyer via a foreign partnership, requested to dismiss the investor’s claim in limine, arguing that Israel is not the proper forum to hear the dispute. The Supreme and District Courts dismissed the motion due to […]
Some statutory provisions protecting a residential tenant cannot be canceled in a lease agreement
Real estate in Israel and around the world
Dispute Resolution
An apartment owner and a tenant signed a lease agreement, under which a security check was deposited and it was stipulated that the tenant must pay a penalty if it does not find an alternate tenant in the event of an early departure. The tenant left the apartment mid-lease and did not find an alternate […]
A website may publish public verdicts and is not obligated to remove them upon request of a person appearing in such verdicts
Privacy, GDPR, Confidentiality and protection of reputation
Dispute Resolution
A legal website automatically collected judgments published by the Directorate of Courts and published legal proceedings involving an individual over the years. The publications included identifying details such as: ID number, signature, and personal information regarding his medical condition, all from public proceedings. The Court dismissed the demand of the person whose details were included […]