A director and a controlling shareholder of the company filed a claim asking the court to recognize him as an employee of the company and to grant him all the rights to which he is entitled to as an employee, for the services he provided to the company as a director. The court held that in order to determine the nature of the relations between the parties and to determine whether labor relations existed between them, it is not sufficient to determine the agreements between the parties. Also, a director acting only as part of his position on the board, and even if he receives any compensation for that service, is not considered as an employee of the company. Since in this case the director failed to prove by the combined test that there are indicators that he is an employee of the company (since this was not his only job, since he did not have an office in the company, and many other indicators), the court rejected the claim.
Published in Afik News 231 24.05.2017
Related articles
One cannot deduct from an employee’s salary to cover future expenses
Sports Law
Labor Law
Dispute Resolution
Wage deductions under the component of a “deposit” were made from the salary of a brazilian football player who played for the Maccabi Haifa football club during his final months of employment. The said deductions were intended to secure the payment of the player’s future expenses, such as debts for traffic fines, housing bills, and […]
A Broker may be entitled to brokerage fees from related parties in the event that it served as an “effective cause” for the transaction
Mergers and Acquisitions
Dispute Resolution
Commercial, Banking and Financial
A middleman entered into an agreement with parties to an acquisition transaction, under which it was intended to receive brokerage fees. After the deal fell through, some of the involved parties established a new company that ultimately executed the deal and made the acquisition, without paying the brokerage fees. The Court held that the middleman […]
The Maritime Court in Israel has the jurisdiction to arrest any vessel anchored in Israel and to hear in rem claims against it
Maritime, Aviation and Transportation Law
Dispute Resolution
A fuel supplier from Dubai, United Arab Emirates, supplied fuel in Turkey and Malta to a Russian-registered cargo ship and sought to enforce a maritime lien against the vessel in Haifa in respect of a debt. Meanwhile, the ship was sold to another owner who repudiated the fuel supplier’s maritime lien. The Court dismissed the […]
In a commercial independent contractor agreement, a party does not have the unilateral authority to impose an interim state of unpaid suspension during a dispute
Commercial, Banking and Financial
Labor Law
Dispute Resolution
Natan Zehavi, a Radio Le-Lo Hafsaka broadcaster provided broadcasting services to the radio station as an independent contractor. Following a controversial on-air statement, the station suspended the broadcaster without pay and refused to reinstate him without receiving new financial guarantees on his part. However, the station refrained from formally terminating the agreement, thereby keeping his […]