Cellular operator purchased cell phones and imported them to Israel while some of the devices were purchased, for promotional and spare parts, at a reduced or free cost. The Customs Authority required to calculate the value of the transaction in accordance with the value of the products and not in accordance with the reduced price at which they were actually purchased. The court ruled that customs fees should be paid in accordance with the actual amount paid and not in accordance with the normal goods price. Customs payment is in accordance with the percentage of customs stipulated in regulations double the value of the goods, except for goods that are subject to customs exemption law. In addition, some goods also have a sales tax, which is similarly calculated. In principle, only when the value of the goods cannot be estimated according to the value of the transaction - the price actually paid or payable under the transaction, for example when the consideration cannot be calculated or there are conditions for payment, the customs authority may assess the goods according to similar products. Here, the cellular operator purchased the cell phones as part of a deal where he received some of the discounted promotional devices while pledging to give them to public opinion leaders and renters for free. In addition, they received 5% cost-free devices, in exchange for releasing the supplier from warranty duties on the products he provided and subject to the additional devices to not be sold to customers, is an economic transaction for all purposes, where the value of the supplier's warranty removal is embodied in the price of the devices supplied free of charge. Therefore, the price of the instruments for customs purposes should be examined according to the price actually paid and not according to the value of the goods.
Published in Afik News 290 28.08.2019
Related articles
Under certain circumstance a taxpayer who has underpaid tax may be exempt from paying the tax
Taxation and Government Incentives and Funding
Dispute Resolution
Vehicle importers underpaid tax due to a lack of clarity in the regulation regarding the determination of the green score for plug-in vehicles imported from the USA, as determined in the Ministry of Transportation’s procedure. The Court held that the importers are to pay the missing tax. A taxpayer must pay true tax even if […]
A lease of less than five years does not need to be in writing or signed
Real Estate
Dispute Resolution
An apartment owner sought to forfeit the bank guarantee given to her by the tenant when the tenant withdrew from the lease a week before she moved in, contending that the agreement was not signed but only negotiations took place and drafts were exchanged between the parties. The Court dismissed the tenant’s claim to declare […]
A bank guarantee that was attached in an out-of-date wording due to a failure to duly update the bidders on the need to change the wording will not be disqualified
Public Law, Environment and Tenders
Dispute Resolution
A tenders committee chose two bidders as the winners of the tender even though the bank guarantee they submitted did not match the updated wording required in the framework of the clarification process. A bidder in the tender demanded that the decision of the tenders committee be revoked and to declare it as the winner […]
Performing work for different companies related to the employer does not automatically generate an employee-employer relationship
Labor Law and Immigration
Dispute Resolution
A CFO of a discount store chain, who was fired from his job, demanded that six companies included in the chain, for which he performed bookkeeping and financial management work, be recognized as his employers. The Labor Court rejected the employee’s claim against the six companies of the chain group and held that the mere […]